This week on The Business of Giving, the focus is on one of the most distressing — and solvable — crises in America today: medical debt.

Each year, millions of families are forced to choose between paying their bills and getting the care they need. But what if there were a way to erase that debt — not just for a few, but for thousands at a time?

That’s exactly what Undue Medical Debt does. Led by CEO Allison Sesso, the organization buys medical debt the way a for-profit company would — but instead of collecting it, they forgive it. The return on investment? For every $1 donated, $100 of medical debt is wiped away.

As Allison explains:
“So, what we do, we buy medical debt for pennies on the dollar. We mimic a for-profit debt buyer, except we turn that market for medical debt on its head, and we do it for charitable purposes.”

Allison also shares how a nurse working during the pandemic found herself in medical debt at the very hospital where she worked — a stark example of how broken the system is, and why it must change.
Here is my conversation with Allison Sesso, CEO of Undue Medical Debt.

President and CEO of Undue Medical Debt

Denver: Undue Medical Debt was born from former debt collectors who saw the system’s flaws up close. What was it about their vision, Allison, and the medical debt crisis itself, that pulled you to lead this organization?

Allison: It’s a great question. For me, having worked in the social services field for so long and working with hundreds of nonprofits in New York City, I appreciated that medical debt set this interface between a broken economic system that hurt obviously people that are in poverty, but also people near poverty and even above poverty.

So it’s an economic crisis, while also being a failure of the way we finance healthcare and a healthcare access crisis. And I fully understood that, again, understanding what the various struggles are with people in low-income communities and getting so many different pieces of assistance from various social service interventions.  And so when I stumbled upon this organization, at the time, RIP Medical Debt, that was looking for new leadership, I thought: What an incredible issue to be able to lift up! It’s really at this centerpiece of these two issues of economic breakdowns and healthcare financing breakdowns.

And so, I really wanted to lean into that, and I also understood that the model itself was wholly unique. Having a really good sense of all of the nonprofit models of interventions that were out there, I had a really good grasp of the uniqueness, the whole uniqueness of the RIP, at the time, Medical Debt, and now Undue Medical Debt model.

“So, what we do, we buy medical debt for pennies on the dollar. We mimic a for-profit debt buyer, except we turn that market for medical debt on its head, and we do it for charitable purposes.”

Denver: Let me pick up on that because I’m sure listeners are saying, What is that uniqueness? What is so different or innovative about this? Share that.

Allison: Yeah. So, what we do, we buy medical debt for pennies on the dollar. We mimic a for-profit debt buyer, except we turn that market for medical debt on its head, and we do it for charitable purposes.

So we buy that debt, medical debt, using donated dollars, and we’re able to take $1 and relieve a hundred dollars of medical debt. You ratchet that up and then get multiples of medical debt being able to be relieved for pennies on the dollar.

So I think what it does is it really creates an incredible return on investment for philanthropists. And it really allows anyone to be a philanthropist. That’s the beauty of it. We get large donations, we get small donations, and everyone can be part of this amazing thing that we are getting rid of medical debt, and it’s instantaneous. I think that’s the other beauty of it.

A lot of social interventions take time. You have to really be patient. You have to give someone an intervention, like an afterschool program, and then hope that years later, it will make sure that the kid does better successfully, et cetera. And you can measure that with their income level, et cetera.

But for this, you really buy the medical debt; you get rid of it and you say: This is how much medical debt we were able to get rid of and what that means for the individual.

Denver: Fantastic. Well, if you ever wanted to make a big difference in this world, you certainly found the right job, didn’t you?

Allison: I did, yeah. I’m very grateful to have this role.

Denver: So, Allison, what was the most shocking thing you discovered about how medical debt actually works in America?

Allison: Well, honestly, the fact that you can buy medical debt for pennies on the dollar speaks volumes to this issue. And I think that that’s what’s the most striking piece of this for me.

Why is it that there’s at least $250 billion of medical debt out there, which is just insane volume overall? So why is it that I can take somebody’s $1 and get rid of a hundred dollars of medical debt? Why is that possible? It’s because the people that owe those debts can’t afford to pay them.

So that is very clearly a mismatch between what we’re expecting people to pay and what they can pay. And so I zeroed in on that, and I really understood that what we expect people to pay out of their own pockets is just vastly off. And that means that the healthcare’s finance system is really broken in so many ways, and that hospitals are taking these… just writing them off and seeing them as losses. And that’s really broken.

And then what it’s doing is– it’s undermining people’s willingness to go get the care they need. And what people are doing is they’re taking that in, in a way that’s undermining their very own health. So the very healthcare system that was supposed to be making people well and make them better is undermining their health because they’re scared to go get the care because of the financial impact.

They avoid the follow-up care that’s being recommended for them. And they’re holding onto this intense anxiety that undermines their wellbeing and undermines their health in really intense ways.

Denver: Yeah, speak a little bit more about that because I’m always curious about the impact that this must have on the individual, on their families, and on their futures. Talk a little bit about that.

Allison: Yeah. I mean, it’s amazing when I walk around the world, I feel like when people find out what I do, I can’t tell you, like so many people stop me and say, “Oh, I’m so grateful for what you do. I had this experience…. my neighbor had this experience… my mother had this experience.”

Unfortunately, what I learned is that it’s a very common American experience– having medical debt or just struggling to pay for healthcare. What happens to the individuals that we help, which I love, is the way our model works– is we find the medical debt, and then we relieve it without anybody. There’s no application, which is one of the benefits of the program.

And so people get these surprise letters in the mail that say, Your medical debt has been relieved; it is gone. You don’t have to worry about it. You’re free and clear. And so the reactions that we get from that, and we have an anthropologist on our team…. and she has the best job. It’s to talk to these individuals and really understand what it’s meant to get that debt relieved.

And the reactions are… at first, there’s often disbelief, of course, right? I mean, we’re skeptical people. It’s a normal reaction. But then when they realize it’s real, they’re brought to tears because it has felt like this incredible burden over them– even by the way if it’s not a huge debt– like sometimes it’s a $200 debt, could be that small, but they feel like, I’ve been wanting to pay this.

But I’m living paycheck to paycheck. $200 actually matters to whether or not I’m going to make the rent or be able to buy food this week. For other people, it’s a larger debt and reminds them often of a health event that they had that was a negative experience, right? It could be a woman that had complications with her pregnancy, or a cancer scare, or an accident that you had and this thing happened to you.

And then on top of that, we’re throwing further salt into that wound by saying, Yeah, we know that you got hurt, and the hospital helped you out, and that’s great. And you’re physically better, but now here’s this big bill that you’re going to have to deal with, and it’s going to weigh on you. And so the sense of relief that we hear from people is just palpable.

Denver: Yeah. Yeah. Showing my age, the 1950s, The Millionaire, I remember that show. And he would come and give people a million dollars and things of that sort, which was great.

I had a guy on the show recently, Allison, and he was saying that sometimes people don’t understand about debt, whether it’s $2,000 of debt or $200,000 of debt, it really doesn’t make any difference. They can’t pay either. They’re both so far beyond their station at this moment that they’re paralyzed by either number.

Allison: Yeah. And they feel like failures. That’s the thing. People just aren’t paying their bills. Like once in a while, we’ll hear an argument that, Well, if you pay people’s medical bills for them and you do this surprise thing, people are going to stop paying. I don’t think that’s true at all. That’s not what we’re hearing from the individuals that we’re helping.

What we’re hearing is that people desperately want to pay, but you can’t get blood from a stone. Their income just isn’t there to pay it. And so again, going back to what I said earlier, those expectations of what they’re supposed to pay out of pocket and the realities are not aligned.

I mean, premiums these days for health insurance are insane. And so people are trying their best to pick an insurance plan that they can afford, which often means that they’re picking an insurance plan that has high deductibles.

Denver: Right.

Allison: So when they go to use the care, they’re expected to pay $2,000 to $5,000 out of pocket that they don’t have.

Denver: How do you prioritize which debts to tackle?

Allison: Yeah, so that’s one of my favorite questions and one of my favorite things to answer is that everyone that qualifies gets their debt relieved if we can access their debt. So we buy medical debt pennies on the dollar in bulk. And so when we work with a hospital, we have this amazing proprietary debt engine that we actually created.

We have a team of engineers that actually developed it. Like we have these guys that are just creating code and created this incredible debt engine. And what it does is it takes a file from the hospital or other healthcare provider, and it identifies everyone that is 400% of poverty or below, which is roughly a little more than a hundred thousand dollars a year for a family of three, and pulls all those people out.

And also, if you’re above that income level,  but you have a debt that’s high. So if it’s 5% or more of your income, we will also flag that and buy that debt. And that’s usually like the bulk of the file, which again, just further supports my idea that the people that want to pay are paying and the people who can’t pay are not paying, right? This is not about willingness to pay, it’s about ability to pay.

So we’ve identified all of those people in the file that qualify, and then we buy all of those debts, and then we send the letters out to all those individuals and let them know we bought their debts. So to qualify, you don’t have to do any application. And if you qualify and we find your debt, you will get a letter from us.

“We’ve worked with hundreds of hospitals across the country, and it’s because they recognize that they want to help the individuals as well, that this is a problem for them, and that the bad debt that’s sitting there is actually undermining people’s health, it’s undermining their wellbeing, and that they do put the community first.”

Denver: I don’t want to gloss over this. We’ve mentioned it a couple times. But you’re saying that you partner with hospitals, and you buy debt pennies on the dollar. That’s got to be a pretty delicate dance. I’m sure a lot of people are saying, How do you do that? What’s the magic? Tell us how those partnerships have been formed and why hospitals agree to do this.

Allison: Yeah, look, I think that the system is even broken for hospitals, right? I mean, they also are in this insurance company. That’s how they want to get paid from insurance companies. But increasingly, the people walk into the door of the hospital with a certain type of insurance level; they can’t control that.

So somebody walks in with a health insurance plan that has an expectation that the person pays $6,000 deductible before the insurance company will pay anything. They’re supposed to go after that person for that $6,000, even if the person doesn’t have the means.

The hospitals that we’ve talked to, they don’t love doing that work. They don’t like billing. They don’t want to go after the individuals, but that’s how the system is set up. Now some hospitals, are they aggressive? Do they sell their debt? Do they… hire collection agencies that are aggressive? Absolutely. And I’m not excusing any of that behavior.

I’m just saying that the incentives are there, and the way the system is set up is so that hospitals are put in a difficult position where they do have to do that billing. So for me, when we work with a hospital, a lot of them have very robust… and increasingly they’re leaning into this… financial assistance programs.

Now they should be in our mind, and we’re working a lot with hospitals to try to encourage them to do more of this, pre-qualify people the way we do for those programs. Don’t make them do an elaborate application process. Look up the person’s information on your own. That’s what we do.

We buy income data to find out if people qualify for our program, and then just give them the free care. I mean, that’s what charity care or financial assistance programs should be doing. Some hospitals do that, some don’t. Some states are requiring hospitals to do that increasingly, which is interesting to watch.

But I would say that lots and lots of hospitals work with us. We’ve worked with hundreds of hospitals across the country, and it’s because they recognize that they want to help the individuals as well, that this is a problem for them, and that the bad debt that’s sitting there is actually undermining people’s health; it’s undermining their wellbeing, and that they do put the community first.

So I think the hospitals that work with us are putting community first above their bottom lines. And at the end of the day, I also know that they realize that they’re not going to make money, and they’re not going to solve any of their revenue problems on the backs of these poor individuals anyway.

Denver: Right, right. They’re just stuck. It’s like flying over an airport, circling around forever and never going anywhere and never getting anything done. And it’s a burden to carry this stuff on your books forever. It just is. What’s it doing there? What good is it doing? Why are we frozen and why are we paralyzed?

You mentioned states a second ago, what’s happening on the policy front around medical debt… maybe some of the successes and some the frustrations?

Allison: Yeah, I would say the biggest thing on my mind right now is, well, there’s two things. One, we have, at the national level, some severe cuts to Medicaid that are really going to create severe problems if they’re enacted. There’s a $715 billion cut to Medicaid. It rolls back a lot of the progress we made with the ACA, which I am not saying was perfect, but pulling the little amount of support that we have away is not a way to solve a problem.

I often… I have this coffee mug that cracks me up that says, “Government, if you’ve seen our problems, wait till you see our solutions.” And that’s what this particular moment makes me think about. They’re just undermining the little support that we have by cutting this Medicaid.

And what that’s going to do is it’s really going to, if enacted, is it’s going to not only cut off care for millions and millions of people in terms of insurance access– which will increase medical debt– but it will also, because there’ll be less people walking in the door with insurance to begin with, it’ll make it harder for hospitals to be more generous on financial assistance, and it will also make insurance premiums for everybody go up.

So it’s going to make the cost of healthcare higher for everyone. It’s not just going to impact the people on Medicaid. But the other thing that I think is really important, and this isn’t a solution to the fundamental underlying problem, but it helps with one of the major impacts, at the tail end of the Biden administration, the CFPB passed a rule that said that medical debt shouldn’t be on credit reports anymore.

And I think that we are very much supportive of that because it’s clear, as I’ve obviously been saying, that whether or not you pay a medical debt does not indicate whether or not you’re credit-worthy. It’s not a good indicator because it’s really a systems problem, not an individual responsibility problem.

And so that has been rolled back by the Trump administration. They actually joined the debt collector side in terms of the lawsuits, which just doesn’t make a lot of sense. And the thing is, there’s so much bipartisan support. People on the left and the right, when you ask them about this, they talk about the fact that it is really a systems failure, not an individual failure, which is very different from other kinds of debt where people feel a personal responsibility plays a role.

Denver: Absolutely.

Allison: And so that to me is a real problem. But the saving grace, I guess, here is state action, to your point and earlier. There’s like 10 states that have enacted rules that say you can’t put medical debt on credit reports, which is great. And there’s many more that are on the cusp of passing laws like this, and we’re talking conservative states and liberal states.

So again, it shows you the bipartisan aspect of this. For example, Florida and Maine both have put… not full bans on putting it on credit reports, but real limits on what can be put on credit reports. Just to give you an example. So states are taking action on this issue, which I really like to see.

Denver: What’s the impact of having medical debt lifted from an individual? I see so many positive stories on it, but then there’s also stories out there saying that mental health and improved credit don’t result from that. What are your observations about those debates that go on, or those findings that we have?

Allison: Yeah, I think that it’s a difficult thing to measure. I mean, we are, as an organization that’s doing this unique model, I think we have a responsibility to really understand the depth of the impact that we’re having. I also don’t think that what we’re doing is a silver bullet, right? I mean, the thing is we’re talking about removing one piece of the puzzle that’s a complex mosaic for individuals and for families.

You are usually dealing with multiple debts, multiple financial constraints, and we’re taking one piece away in a very cost-efficient, low-cost way, which is wonderful and helpful. I don’t want to pretend like this is going to change the person’s life and turn it around; it is going to remove one of the burdens that they’re facing.

Now, what does that mean for the individual? It means a sense of hope. How do you measure that? That’s not an easy thing to measure. And it also depends on what else they have going on. I think at different income levels, it could have different impacts. If this really is for a low-income individual  that’s at the poverty level, again, they’re still going to have real financial constraints.

Now, if you’re talking about someone that’s at 400% of the poverty level, removing this could be actually more meaningful potentially for that individual. It doesn’t mean it doesn’t have a meaning for the person at the poverty level, but it could have a greater meaning for the person at 400% of poverty.

I think the impacts are: we’ve seen that it does have a positive impact on credit. There’s no question about that. Now how extensive is the impact? I think that still needs to be continued to be studied. Does it have the impact on people’s willingness to go back and get care? I think we need to do some deeper dives to understand their willingness to go back and get care.

So again, I think that there’s a lot more to be studied on this issue, and we are actually leaning into that and hoping to fund some of that studying in the near future, because we want to make sure that not only do we understand what this means, but that we can effectively tell the story of medical debt and what it means for families across the United States.

Denver: It’d be a lot easier if people weren’t quite so complex, but we really are.

Allison: Yes, we are. Yes, we are.

“We want to break the stigma around medical debt. We want to make sure that the finger is squarely pointed at the system and not the individual.”

Denver: Talk a little bit about the storytelling. I know that you want recipients to feel empowered and not pitied, and I also know there’s a moral injustice story here. I think the way this is framed is really fascinating. Give us your thoughts on how you frame it and how you think this story should be told to really be most impactful.

Allison: Yeah, so I think that there’s been many times over the course of history where public opinion changes and people understand more deeply what a social issue… it means to individuals and to communities.

And I think that has a lot to do with people’s willingness to stand up and tell their stories. And that’s why we’ve been very intentional in leaning into the storytelling. We want to break the stigma around medical debt. We want to make sure that the finger is squarely pointed at the system and not the individual.

These moral hazard arguments that have traditionally circulated are no longer really landing with communities because we’ve talked to communities extensively about this, and they’re clearly pointing to the system. They’re blaming insurance companies, hospitals, drug companies, you name it.

They name everybody else except the individual because they realized that not only have they experienced this themselves, but they’ve seen, again, their friends, their neighbors, et cetera. And I think every one of us has dealt with a situation where you go to the doctor, and you end up on hours of fighting with the insurance company or the hospital about what you’re supposed to pay, et cetera.

And that’s frustrating and it’s a common experience. And so I think we’ve really leaned into that. And so we have an anthropologist on our team, again, who I mentioned earlier, whose job it is to lift up those stories, talk to people. She does long-form interviews. We get shorter… just blurbs from people about what it’s meant to have medical debt.

And we actually have a qualitative… this is one of my favorite things… we’ve got this qualitative database where we sort of categorize the common themes we’re hearing from people, so that we can actually create some of that data, that rich data, to understand what this means for people in terms of delaying care, in terms of the anxiety, in terms of the financial impacts, in terms of the credit impacts, et cetera.

So storytelling to us is really key, and fundamentally our goal is to put ourselves out of business. I want to be super clear about that with everybody… and we really mean it. I know that people that work here sort of get like, Wait! What? What’s about that? Unfortunately, I don’t think that’s going to happen tomorrow.

Denver: Yeah.

Allison: But we do, and I think it’s through the storytelling that we will help the country get to a place where we do better on the financing of healthcare. I don’t think it’s going to happen tomorrow, but I do think that the tide is moving in the right direction on this issue because of the willingness of individuals to talk about their experiences and the commonality of it.

Denver: That’s great. I love you have an anthropologist on the team. I had a guy on from Patagonia on the show the other day, and he was the director of Philosophy. So there’s some really new nifty job titles out there.

Let’s stick with the storytelling. If you could sit down, Allison, with one recipient who received that debt forgiveness letter, who might that be, and what would their story be?

Allison: Oh, there’s so many good stories. Some of the stories that I think of are the people that are working in the healthcare industry themselves because I just feel like they even are impacted by this. There’s a story of a nurse… it’s a little bit older story, but it sticks with me because she was working during the pandemic.

And she, I don’t remember the specifics of how she got sick, but she got sick. She had two young kids and she had been working at the hospital. She wasn’t a doctor, but I believe she was a nurse. And she ended up, because of her illness, in her own medical debt at the very hospital she worked at.

And I would love to talk to her about what that felt like to be dedicating yourself to helping other people with their own health needs, and then falling ill yourself and the system really turning against you in that moment.

And then needing the help of an organization like us in order to get out of it because you, yourself, do not have the coverage, even though you work for an institution who should understand this more deeply, to get the care that you need and to have to pay more out of pocket than you are able to.

Denver: The variance of how people might react to that is so wide and so fascinating. I think you picked a good one there.

In closing, Allison, you just said your ultimate dream is to put Undue Medical Debt out of business. What’s one bold step you’re taking right now towards that future?

Allison: I think it’s in the storytelling and the policy work that we’re doing. I mean, we are really leaning into ensuring that this issue remains bipartisan. We want to really tell, show everyone that the issue is a systems issue, and show frankly people that are running for office and that are in office that this is a winning issue for them politically.

So I think that this issue is not anyone’s number one issue, but I feel like it’s everyone’s number three issue.

Denver: Got you.

Allison: And that to me, in this moment in the United States where there’s so much division, I see unity here. And so for me, we really want to lean into that piece of what we’re doing. We’re going to keep picking up the pieces. I mean, we’ve relieved $15 billion of medical debt to date. We just bought a portfolio of $30 billion.

Denver: Down in Florida. Fantastic.

Allison: And that’s huge, right? That’s $45 billion of medical debt right there. But we’ve got a $250 billion problem on our hands, and we’ve got more debt being created every day. So us relieving the debt is not the final answer.

So I think for us, what I’d like to do is keep pushing the envelope and telling those stories through this debt relief so that we can get to a place where we have bolder solutions at a national and even state level that stops putting the problem of this financing of healthcare into the laps of the patients who are trying to get care.

Denver: For listeners who want to take action to try to help relieve that $250 billion of debt and get all you guys there unemployed, what’s one thing that they can do today to help?

Allison: You should start a campaign or make a donation. So unduemedicaldebt.org. You can easily sign up and do your own campaign. If you’re in New York City, you could be running the marathon. You could be supporting some of the runners that we’re doing there, for example. There’s so many different campaigns running at once, so I encourage people to do that.

And importantly, tell your stories about medical debt. Don’t be shy about it.

Denver: Fantastic. Yeah, it becomes contagious. It just gets into that eco.. and just starts to spread. I want to thank you so much for being here today, Allison. It was a real delight to have you back on the show.

Allison: Thank you so much for having me.


To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com 

Share This: