
Founder, Fair Trade USA
Denver: Welcome to The Business of Giving, Paul.
Paul: Thank you, Denver. Great to see you.
Denver: Paul, what did living in Nicaragua for 11 years, starting with that one-way ticket, teach you about dignity, about power and systems that you would’ve never learned in a classroom?
Paul: Oh wow. That’s a big question. Thank you. You start with the easy ones, huh? So Denver, I went to Nicaragua straight out of school at the tender age of 22 because I had always felt sympathy and empathy for farmers. My grandfather was a farm worker in Oklahoma, grew up during the Great Depression.
I grew up hearing stories about how hard life was on the farm, and I always felt a calling, and so I went to Nicaragua. I went to work with farmers and to see if I could help. And I ended up working for my first seven years there. I was there for a total of 11 years. Got married, had a kid. I became Pablo.
Denver: I know, that’s right. And you knew Spanish better than English by the time you came home.
Paul: Well, I did for quite a while, actually. Yeah. Dreaming and all that. But for my first seven years there, I had a chance, Denver, to work on so many great community development projects funded by well-intentioned international aid agencies, and all focused on helping farmers on a journey out of poverty.
And I thought that was cool and I thought aid was the way to really improve lives. But sadly, what I found working on so many of these projects was that we actually weren’t that effective in many cases. And sometimes, we just created dependency on foreign aid. And I became very disillusioned with that.
And there is certainly a place for foreign aid. There’s certainly a place for disaster relief. I’m not saying there isn’t. Philanthropy is very important around the world. But what I came to see was that more often than not, we ignored the market. We didn’t help farmers learn how to navigate and be successful in the global market.
And so I had kind of a major career pivot in 1990 when I heard about fair trade and the slogan– the philosophy of the fair traders was trade, not aid. And their whole approach was: Hey, let’s help farmers add value to their product and sell in a more direct way to the global market.
And that will enable them to improve their lives, basically kind of a bootstraps approach, improve their lives based on their own efforts rather than on some government or international agency. And so, that was kind of my… sometimes I call it my capitalist epiphany, because I thought until then…I thought the market was the problem, that capitalism was the problem.
Capitalism was victimizing these farmers. Money lenders and unscrupulous buyers, they were preying on small, uneducated, poor farmers in the hinterlands who didn’t know that they had choices. And so I thought capitalism was the problem.
When I started this fair trade co-op in 1990, what I learned was actually markets, market forces, companies and consumers can be incredibly powerful allies in our efforts to sustainably develop communities around the world. And so, my capitalist epiphany was I went from anti-capitalist to social capitalist and began to be a true believer in the power of market-based solutions, if you will.
Denver: Aha moments are wonderful things to have. Sometimes you only need to have one in your entire life, and they can change the whole trajectory.
But let me pick up on what you just said, because I see a challenge here. You have created… not you, the international aid has created dependency among these farmers. So then how do you get them beyond that sense of limiting beliefs that they’re not just laborers, but they’re owners and they’re exporters. That’s a tall task.
Paul: Yeah. Well, I will say this, I’ve been working in international development since 1983 for more than 40 years. And I have seen a tremendous evolution of the international development community, agencies like USAID, nonprofit organizations like Oxfam and CARE and the like. And the evolution that I’ve seen is one of now embracing market linkage and the role of markets and the role of public/private partnerships as a way to be more effective at poverty alleviation and sustainable community development around the world.
So I will say that aid, if you will, has really grown up over the last 40 years in understanding the critical role of the market to enable better social and environmental outcomes. But to your point about farmers, limiting beliefs is a good way to describe it because early in my career, what I found to be true was that farmers knew they could farm, but when they looked in the mirror, so to speak, they didn’t see a trucker, they didn’t see a mill operator, they didn’t see a banker, they didn’t see an exporter.
And so one of the things that I discovered when I started Nicaragua’s first fair trade export co-op in 1990… and we grew that to 3,000 families, we were exporting millions of pounds of coffee to fair trade buyers around the world– and I witnessed one-acre farmers usually illiterate or semi-literate farmers who never could imagine themselves taking control of these other economic activities.
I saw a journey of self-confidence. A journey where they got organized, created economies of scale, and this is key in order to be able to transform their product, add value, and export direct. And so, in a sense, they learned how to wear multiple hats, not just the farmer hat, but the trucker and the banker and the exporter.
And it was incredibly inspiring, Denver, to see this journey of self-confidence in farmers that just a few years earlier could never have imagined the things that they would be doing.
Denver: Yeah, that is great. Well, you took this grassroots, justice-driven movement and built a scalable certification program.
How did you do that and preserve the soul of Fair Trade while making it work in places like Europe and the United States?
Paul: Yeah. Yeah, it’s a great question. I mean, let me start just by not assuming that all of our listeners know what fair trade is, so I’m going to give you the 30-second overview…
Denver: A 101. Yeah.
Paul: Well, look, fair trade is definitely a philosophy and an approach to grassroots development, but it’s also a rigorous 200-point checklist of social, labor and environmental criteria that farms and factories have to implement in order to be a part of the fair trade market.
Those farms and factories get audited every year; so an independent auditor comes in and verifies that they’re not using child labor, that they’re not using toxic pesticides and so on. And when they pass their audit, then these farms and factories are eligible to sell at a premium to our 2,000 market partners.
And when I say market partners, I’m talking about Whole Foods and Costco and Walmart and amazing companies that are paying a little bit more back to farmers for producing in a more sustainable way. So Fair Trade is a certification.
And when you, as a consumer, see that Fair Trade Certified label on a package of coffee or bananas or now, manufactured goods, like shirts and furniture and so on, you know that the farmers and the workers received a better wage, were treated better, and were able to invest in their communities and improve their lives.
So how will you grow a market for something like that? It’s not enough just to go to companies, in my experience, and say, Hey, fair trade is the right thing to do, right? Paying a living wage to the farmers and workers who make your company run is the right thing to do. I mean, of course it’s the right thing to do, but there needs to be a business case.
And so what I’ve spent the better part of the last 26 years doing is helping companies find value in this motto of ethical sourcing so that it’s win-win. Michael Porter at Harvard wrote a lot about this notion of shared value.
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: A notion that the more effective solutions to social and environmental challenges is not redistribution.
Like if I went to Whole Foods and said, Hey, take a margin hit, take lower profits in order to pay your farmers more money, I wouldn’t get very far with that. But shared value is the notion that through something like fair trade, new value is created in which farmers get more money, Whole Foods derives value, and consumers also get a great product that also makes them feel good.
And so, therein lies kind of the secret sauce of fair trade and things like it, which is: How do you make sure that there’s a business case?
“…fair trade is a way of making sure that those suppliers get more money and are rewarded for producing in a sustainable way.”
Denver: How do you? Give me 30 seconds on that. I’m Walmart, I’m Chobani, I’m Patagonia. You’re coming.
Paul: Three things.
Denver: You’re going to say it’s going to be win-win. How do I win from my perspective?
Paul: Absolutely. And I’ve got numbers to prove it. Three things.
Denver: Okay.
Paul: Number one, fair trade and other expressions of ethical sourcing are going to give you traceability and transparency in your supply chain. So if you’re Walmart, you want to know who the end farmer is. Not just buying from some supplier who says, Yeah, don’t worry. Like there’s no child labor on the farms that we’re bringing product in for you.
No, you want to see all the way back to the farm. You want to be able to mitigate reputational risk through supply chain transparency. So that’s value number one.
Denver: Oh yeah.
Paul: Mitigation of risk.
Number two, beyond that, the supply chain is so key to the success of brands and retailers here in the US. It needs to be a reliable supply chain. We learned during COVID, supply chain disruptions can really mess with your business… So a more reliable supplier, farmer or factory owner that delivers on time at the right quality, that has value for the company. And so fair trade is a way of making sure that those suppliers get more money and are rewarded for producing in a sustainable way. And that has value for the company.
Number three, the evidence shows that consumers in the US today are increasingly reading the label. They want to know, is this product healthy? Is it safe? We also want to know, is it good for the environment, or is it like supporting deforestation of the Amazon, right? Is it good for people, or is there child labor in my chocolate bar?
And so this rising movement of what I call conscious consumerism is now anywhere from a third to two-thirds of American consumers, depending on whose data you believe. Either way, it’s tens of millions of people who are increasingly looking for social and environmental value in the products that they buy.
And that’s a growing consumer segment that companies want to tap into. So when you put the Fair Trade label on your package, or the non-GMO label, or the organic label, or things like that, you’re tapping into a growing consumer segment that is not particularly price-sensitive.
And so that’s kind of the third benefit that we see to companies, when we talk about what’s the business case for Fair Trade. It’s really those three things that most businesses embrace when they join our cause.
Denver: Quite concise and quite compelling. But now I’m going to be the consumer. Okay? I go to the store and I see the Fair Trade label. I’m very impressed. But you know, I’m also looking at other labels, and I got eco-friendly, and I got ethical and I got organic, and I’m like: What does all this mean? Just sort that out for me.
Paul: Yeah, it’s interesting because I think there are folks who are concerned about the proliferation of sustainability labels and the possibility that consumers could just get confused by it all. However, there’s no evidence whatsoever to suggest that conscious consumers are looking at the mini labels, not understanding what they mean in saying, Oh, to hell with sustainability! I’m going to go buy something that has no labels.
If you care about the attributes of the product, you end up doing your research. And so evidence of that is not just the data in consumer research, but just the fact that more and more products are labeled. We see a growth in different approaches to auditing and verifying sustainability claims.
And so we work with companies that almost have like a NASCAR effect on their packaging. They’ve got the Fair Trade label and the organic label and the non-GMO label, and maybe the gluten-free label. Those companies are not struggling to make sales.
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: Because their consumers are confused about what it all means. No, those companies are growing, right? And so the proof is in the pudding.
If companies that seek certification as a way to add credibility and verification to their claims, if those companies are thriving, then clearly we’re doing something right. Now, is there a role for consumer education? Absolutely. Fair Trade Certified, our label has 67% consumer awareness. So that’s well over 130 million American adults that recognize our label and say they’ve seen it.
Denver: That’s probably more people know that label than probably who know who the vice president of the United States is right now.
Paul: Maybe.
Denver: You find out those numbers are pretty, pretty striking.
Paul: That’s pretty good, but not all of those people who say they’ve seen the label know what it means.
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: 67% have seen it. About 52% can accurately describe it. So there is a gap. Although I would say, there’s evidence that even people who don’t understand what it means have a positive association with the words ‘Fair Trade Certified.’
Denver: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Paul: But suffice to say, we all have our job cut out for us, which is educating consumers, not just about what Fair trade means, but about the impact that they can have with something as simple as a cup of coffee or a banana or a t-shirt. I mean, that’s why I call my book Every Purchase Matters because we all have the opportunity, through the products that we choose, to reach halfway across the world and help a family keep their kids in school.
It’s incredibly transformative, not just fair trade, but all these expressions of ethical sourcing are incredibly transformative in terms of the impact in the lives of farmers and workers and in the preservation of the environment where they live. And so, small acts of kindness, right, with something as simple as going to the supermarket and choosing a Fair Trade product, you can have an enormous difference in the lives of people around the world.
Denver: Well, the power of compounding. I got one more consumer-centric question for you.
Paul: Yeah.
Denver: Are there consumers out there who make choices with the best of intentions, believing that they’re doing the right thing, or at least not doing any harm, but at the end of the day, they may have unintended negative consequences?
Paul: That’s a good question. It’s interesting because even the most educated, even the most educated and engaged consumer, those that we call conscious consumers, even we often have a hard time finding sustainable choices in every product category.
it’s really easy to find sustainable coffee, but then slide down the aisle a little bit to the chocolate section and there are a few sustainable chocolate initiatives. There’s Fair Trade, there’s organic, there’s Rainforest Alliance. But most chocolate today is not certified by anyone. Where does most of the world’s cocoa come from?
Cocoa is the ingredient that goes into chocolate. About 60% comes from West Africa, from Ivory Coast and Ghana. And it’s been well documented that the incidence of child labor in the cocoa fields of Ghana and Ivory Coast is quite high. Not because farmers don’t care about their kids, but because they’re poor.
And so they need that extra labor in the fields to help support the family. They put their kids to work out of desperation.
Denver: Interesting.
Paul: And so, most people, I dare say, most consumers in the US today don’t know that there’s child labor in their chocolate bar. But if you’re buying something that isn’t certified, then it’s quite likely that there has been exploitation of child labor in that product.
And so I think there are a lot of consumers who just don’t know and who are buying a brand of chocolate because that’s the brand they grew up with.
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: And they’re not thinking about the farming family on the other side of the world that made that chocolate bar possible.
So I think for me, the solution, Denver, is raising awareness and helping consumers. I call it mindful shopping. When we go to the store, being mindful of the fact that everything we buy was made by someone. There’s a family behind every product that we choose. There’s an ecosystem, an environmental impact with everything that we choose. And we have the chance to choose sustainable products and make a difference.
Denver: And that’s what makes every purchase matter. Such a wonderful book is an education unlike any other.
You talked about supply chains a moment ago and really tracking it back or tracing it back to the very beginning. I wonder what the role of technology has done to make that much easier than it had been when you first started this.
Paul: Yeah, there’s definitely a role for technology. We’re seeing it first and foremost in terms of storytelling.
Denver: Uh-huh.
Paul: So the Fair Trade logo on a package of coffee signals to consumers the attributes of fair trade, right? That the farmer got a better price and took care of the natural environment around the farm. But imagine a not-so-distant future in which every package of coffee also had a QR code, that you could scan to meet the farming family that you helped with your purchase. It’s extraordinary.
And that capability now exists because of technological advances, and we’re rapidly in the process of engaging with our now 1 million farmers around the world to give them the technological tools and savvy to upload their stories and to connect that to the brands that are selling their product, so that storytelling becomes a turbo engine of consumer intimacy, if you will, of consumer engagement.
That’s what we’re after. Consumers love stories. We all love stories. And if we knew the face, if we knew the story of the family that we were helping through that package of coffee or that chocolate bar that we’re buying, I think we would do more of it.
“…feedback is a gift, even if it doesn’t feel good in the moment.”
Denver: Yeah. Yeah. Paul, every movement, when it grows and enters the mainstream, eventually faces critique. And I was wondering about this Fair Trade movement. It’s no exception. What critiques do you think are fair and have helped improve the model? And which ones do you think have been unfair and have really missed the mark?
Paul: That’s a great question. I think early on, when we started 26 years ago, our farmers were just getting started, our coffee farm. We started with coffee, and I had worked with coffee farmers in Nicaragua. So it was a product category that I knew. I knew a lot of people in the industry.
And the farmers that we enlisted were doing a great job in terms of taking care of their workers and taking care of the land, but they didn’t necessarily know how to produce the highest quality. And we got a lot of criticism early on from the coffee industry saying basically fair trade is just welfare for farmers that are incapable of producing quality.
And I remember, on a stage at UC Berkeley, back in the day, debating the founder and CEO of Peet’s Coffee, who said, “Don’t give farmers fair trade; teach them how to grow quality, and they’ll make a higher income based on their own efforts rather than on this whole fair trade thing.”
And my counterargument to that is fair trade is going to help these farmers tap into the market in a more direct way, as opposed to selling to middlemen. And by tapping into the market in a direct way, the farmers will be able to hear the market say, If you grow higher quality, I’ll pay you more. And that in fact is what happened.
I would say fair trade coffee did suck early on. And our farmers, to their credit, heard the feedback and started investing in infrastructure and training to improve quality. So fair trade is, because of the premium, it enables these amazing outcomes.
Fair trade farmers invest in health, they invest in education, they invest in better housing. They reforest the areas around their farms. They invest in gender equity and helping lift women out of poverty. They do all these cool social things. But fair trade farmers also invest in infrastructure, right?
Every farmer knows, if you don’t set aside seed for next year, you’re not going to have a harvest. And similarly, with a similar mentality, so many of our fair trade farming groups, including the coffee groups back then, started to invest in improving quality. It was pretty simple– Infrastructure and training.
Fast forward a few years later, fair trade co-ops were starting to win every quality award out there. There’s an annual contest in the coffee industry called the Cup of Excellence. And we started winning five, six years in; we started winning in every single country where our farmers participated.
And so what that showed me was the criticism was valid early on around the quality. We made sure our farmers heard that loud and clear, and they responded and addressed it and overcame it. And I love that.
I’ll give you another example of criticism that was valid and how we responded because feedback is a gift, even if it doesn’t feel good in the moment.
Denver: It sure is.
Paul: I mentioned that fair trade has a premium attached to it. So in other words, when Whole Foods or Walmart or Costco buy fair trade coffee or fair trade produce from the farmers, they have to pay a little bit more money over and above market price, and that’s what enables community development.
Well, what many of those retailers started telling us after the early days was, Hey, we know your premiums are important to the model, but they’re too high. We can’t scale this fair trade model because it’s just too expensive for the consumer. And our response to that early on was, You know what? All the data suggests that consumers are willing to pay more for a socially responsible product, so screw you! Just keep selling.
And, you know… I didn’t really say: Screw you. Sorry…
Denver: That doesn’t… that one, that’d be out of character.
Paul: But didn’t really say that to the CEO of Whole Foods. But what I did say was, Hey, look at the impact. The premium is accomplishing amazing things, so stick with us.
And they stuck with us. But I think over time, we started to see the wisdom and the feedback, which was that in some product categories, the fair trade premium was too high to scale the volume, and so we were kind of locking ourselves into a market niche. And so we ended up responding to that, actually just in the last few years.
How did we respond? We conducted a consultation, a very participatory exercise in which we talked with retailers, we talked with brands, we talked with farmers, we talked with factory owners, and we said, Hey, fair trade right now is kind of a high-premium, low-volume model.
Low volume in the big picture, right? I mean, I certified 6% of all coffee imported into the US last year. That’s hundreds of millions of pounds. So low volume in the big picture, but significant impact nonetheless. But our pitch into the stakeholders was the motto is kind of locked into a market niche. How do we get out of it?
And the overwhelming feedback– not just from the market, from retailers and brands, but also from the farmers– the feedback was, Hey, let’s lower the premium in order to scale the volume. So we started that process two years ago, first in apparel, and then in produce.
So in the case of produce, we lowered the premium from roughly 5 cents a pound on average to 2 cents a pound across the board. And we saw volume jump dramatically. So the end result was incredibly positive in terms of millions of dollars in additional money flowing back to farmers around the world and to factory owners around the world. And in the case of our apparel program, the net result was positive because we ended up listening…
Denver: You listened.
Paul: …and innovating based on that market feedback. So that’s another example of how we were criticized and instead of saying: No, we eventually learned to say: Yes.
Denver: Yes.
Paul: Let’s take this criticism and figure out how together with the rest of the stakeholders, we can make the model better.
“And so I wanted to write the book for two audiences. I wanted to write the book for the business community and the philanthropic community that works in the world of business as well, to kind of shed light on this whole phenomenon of ethical sourcing and conscious capitalism.”
Denver: Yeah. Yes. And perfect way to handle it.
So the book is Every Purchase Matters: How Fair Trade Farmers, Companies, and Consumers Are Changing the World. Why this book, Paul, and why right now?
Paul: Well, I reckon after 26 years of leading Fair Trade USA, I’ve earned the right to tell this story.
Denver: You don’t have to get to that. That’s all we needed to know. Yeah.
Paul: I mean, look, no insider in the Fair Trade movement has ever written the untold story of this movement. I mean, you’ve got 67% of US adults, so tens of millions of people, over 130 million people who know what fair trade is, but they don’t actually know the full story behind the label.
And so I wanted to write the book for two audiences. I wanted to write the book for the business community and the philanthropic community that works in the world of business as well, to kind of shed light on this whole phenomenon of ethical sourcing and conscious capitalism.
There are a lot of companies out there that are trying to figure out how to make their supply chains more responsible and sustainable. And I talk a lot about lessons learned in this book, our successes, but also our colossal failures. And so it is my hope that the business community and that sector of the NGO philanthropic community that works in tandem with business on market-based solutions to poverty and environment and so on, it’s my hope that it will illuminate the path for them.
It’s also written for the consumer because consumers are increasingly hungry for solutions, large and small, that they can be a part of. And so this book helps us understand: There’s ordinary Americans, there’s ordinary consumers– How we can help.
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: And what sustainability is all about, and what these labels are all about… And what does fair trade actually mean? And the story behind the label. And why is this story more relevant and important now than ever before?
I reckon we live in a time when a lot of people feel pretty discouraged with politics, are wondering how they can help. Where we live in a time where deregulation is the name of the game. USAID, the primary instrument of US foreign aid and the primary vehicle for the United States government to help alleviate poverty around the world… USAID is being closed as we speak.
Denver: It’s gone just like that.
Paul: It’s gone. And so a lot of people are wondering, Okay, in the face of this shift in US public policy, what can I do? And what can you do? Well, you don’t have to wait four years to vote for change. You can vote for change this afternoon when you go to the grocery store by choosing sustainable products. Fair Trade or any other sustainable product, you can vote with your dollars for the kind of world that you want to see.
And in the case of Fair Trade, I mean, we directly address global poverty. And so in the face of USAID’s demise, I dare say, private sector initiatives like fair trade are one of the best ways that you and I have as just ordinary individuals to continue to help farming communities and families around the world.
“As Greta Thunberg said, The planet is on fire. If we look at climate change, the impact of storms… If we look at global poverty, all of these problems demand attention. And I don’t think we can wait decades to figure out the solutions at scale. I think we need to lean in. And so for me, the question isn’t: Do we have a more positive future ahead? I believe we do, but rather: What’s the pace of change? Can we pick up the pace?”
Denver: Another thought I had on why now, when I was reading the book, I know you have said capitalism evolves over 50-year arcs, and when I look at conscious capitalism, eh, 25 years in, midpoint, and where are we going? Do we have confidence that we’re on the right path? And what forces do you believe most threaten that vision?
What are those forces that you’re worried about, that you’re trying to give us a booster shot right here at the midpoint to make sure that we stay on the right path?
Paul: I feel a lot of hope and optimism actually about that long-term trajectory, that long-term arc of change that you just referenced. I certainly see it in the 40 years that I’ve been involved in working around global poverty. And then this market-based approach and the business people and their attitudes, business people that I’ve spoken to 30 years ago versus today. It is clear that corporate America is shifting its views toward global supply chains. It’s shifting its views toward the value of sustainability for their business.
I think increasingly, business leaders are overcoming this trade-off mentality of the past where either you could be sustainable, or you could be profitable, but you couldn’t be both, right? And I think that trade-off mentality is giving way now to a new vision and leadership in corporate America where more and more companies realize that sustainability can enable their success. And so when I look at the last 20 years, I feel very hopeful and optimistic about the next 20 years, and I think the pace of change is meaningful.
As Greta Thunberg said, The planet is on fire.
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: If we look at climate change, the impact of storms… If we look at global poverty, all of these problems demand attention. And I don’t think we can wait decades to figure out the solutions at scale. I think we need to lean in. And so for me, the question isn’t: Do we have a more positive future ahead? I believe we do, but rather: What’s the pace of change? Can we pick up the pace?
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: And so therein lies the opportunity that each of us has as individuals, that each of us has as leaders of nonprofits, as leaders in companies. We have a chance to lean into this movement that some call conscious capitalism and this movement that some call conscious consumerism, which I believe hold tremendous hope.
And I believe there’s opportunity there to pick up the pace, and it starts with what you do today.
Denver: That’s right.
Paul: This afternoon at the grocery store, that’s where it starts. Small hacks that have profound impact.
Denver: Well, I have no dinner here at the house, so as soon as this interview is over, I’m going to the grocery store, and I’ll be looking a little bit more sharply.
Paul: There you go.
Denver: Finally, Paul, and I don’t mean to put you on the spot, but you said earlier in our conversation that everybody loves a good story. And you are one of the legendary storytellers in the sector. Do you have a story you’d like to share with listeners?
Paul: Oh, I sure do. So many. There’s a story that I tell at greater length in my book that’s about a Nicaraguan coffee farmer named Santiago Rivera.
And Santiago is very emblematic of the 25 million coffee farmers in the world today. Fourth generation coffee farmer, grew up in poverty. His family had a very small one-acre farm, but he worked his ass off as a young man, saved up enough money and bought his own farm, also a one-acre farm when he was a young man.
And Santiago’s family was so poor that after second grade, he was taken out of school to help the family survive. So he knows how to read and write, but only a second-grade education. And that’s true for so many of the coffee and other commodity-growing families around the world.
So, Santiago, as a young man, had his own farm and joined a farming cooperative with 30 of his neighbors, and they got Fair Trade Certified in 1992 and had a chance to start selling to the fair trade market, and getting a better price, and really having the resources for the first time to invest in their community.
Well, what did they do with the money? First of all, they stayed on the land.
Denver: Okay.
Paul: They were able to make a decent living on the land, so they weren’t forced to immigrate in search of a better livelihood. They could stay home. They were able to keep their kids in school and put three meals a day on the table, which may sound trivial, but for many families around the world, that’s a big deal.
Denver: Sure.
Paul: Early on, Santiago and his neighbors in the first year or two after joining Fair Trade, they had enough money to dig a well in their community and to bring clean drinking water into the village for the first time.
Denver, the number one cause of death in children under the age of five in Africa, Asia, and Latin America, number one cause of death is gastrointestinal disease caused by dirty water. So you clean up the water supply, you save lives.
And that’s what Santiago and his neighbors did. They cleaned up the water supply; they dug a well. They didn’t wait for government to come in or some aid agency to come in and do it for them. They did it themselves with this extra money from fair trade.
Santiago’s daughter, Yolanda, went through grade school, and then she was needed in the fields as well. And so she had to step out of school at the age of 12. One of Santiago’s community’s first investments after the water project was to set up a scholarship fund to send their kids to high school.
Because high school was unusual in those communities. Grade school was common, high school wasn’t. And high school is free, but shoes aren’t, and you can’t go to school if you don’t have shoes on your feet. So the scholarship fund, which was $200 per year per kid– that’s all it took– went to cover uniforms, shoes, and school supplies.
And so Yolanda was able to get back into school, thanks to this $200 a year scholarship fund. She went all the way through high school. She was the first girl in the history of that community, Denver, to finish high school.
Denver: Wow.
Paul: First girl to finish high school. And then she went on, also with a Fair Trade scholarship fund, and went to college. First girl to go to college out of that community. Finished college, studied biology. Finished college and came back to work in the health clinic in their village, and she’s there to this day.
And when I go to visit and I go back to Nicaragua often, I usually go to see Santiago and Yolanda and catch up.
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: When I go, we’re usually sitting on the front porch drinking coffee that they’ve grown on their farm. And invariably, there are all these kids from the village, all these little girls from the village who show up. And I used to think, Oh, they’re showing up to see the crazy gringo who’s descended once a year on the village.
Then I realized, they were hanging on Yolanda’s every word.
Denver: Yeah.
Paul: Those girls saw in Yolanda the possibility of dreams coming true. Because in most rural communities around the world, all you can dream of, if you’re a girl, is being a farmer’s daughter, and then a farmer’s wife.
And what Yolanda showed was that you can aspire to something else if you want to. And for me, that’s what fair trade is all about. It’s about bringing hope to communities that often just don’t have much hope.
Denver: What a wonderful story to end on. The book is Every Purchase Matters: How Fair Trade Farmers, Companies, and Consumers Are Changing the World. And this is a compelling testament to the power of conscious capitalism, showing us how our everyday choices can build a fair and more sustainable world.
I can’t thank you enough for being here today, Paul. It was a real joy to have you on the program.
Paul: Denver, thank you. What a pleasure! And I love your questions. I mean, it’s really fun to be in conversation with someone who’s so thoughtful, and your questions made me think. And I hope I rose to the occasion. It was a great conversation for me.
Denver: Well, thank you. I try to set a high bar, and you cleared it by a mile.
Paul: Thank you, sir. I appreciate you.
To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com
