Welcome to The Business of Giving. I’m your host, Denver Frederick.
Today, I’m joined by Hali Lee. Her book The Big We rethinks philanthropy—shifting it from billionaires to regular folks at the kitchen table, pooling resources through giving circles. I love how she’s turned her Korean geh tradition into a spark for collective change. We’ll explore how she’s shaking up giving, building community, and imagining a future where ‘we’ and not “me” takes the lead.
Denver: Welcome to the business of giving, Hali.

Hali Lee Author, The Big We
Hali: Thanks for having me, Denver.
Denver: Why don’t we start with the basics. What exactly is a giving circle? How does it work, and what makes it different from other forms of philanthropy?
Hali: Great question. So giving circles have been around, I think, since humans have been living in communities. It’s really people coming together to do good together in a way that benefits their families, communities, neighbors, towns. There are lots of cultural traditions that I believe we all come from that undergird this idea of giving circles as applied to American philanthropic practice.
Mine, I’m Korean American and we have something in my culture called a keh. And if you and me and three friends were in a keh together, we would put money into a pot, meet every month, and take turns taking that pot home. I’ve been in lots of silly, fun, frivolous kehs with my girlfriends. My mom and dad were always in a keh when I was a kid growing up in Kansas City.
So I took that idea of putting money into a pot and taking turns taking it home and put a philanthropic twist on it. And that gave birth to the Asian Women Giving Circle, and we’re turning 20 years old this year. But as I’ve been doing this work– just like you, I’ve been in the nonprofit sector for, gosh, 30 years, like my whole working life– I’ve been hearing about a lot of these other cultural forms of shared giving, pooling money, and giving it away.
Like my Mexican American friends call them tandas. You might know some West Indian folks or West African people who call them susu or esusu. Indonesian girlfriends call them arisan. These cultural forms of, I guess, collective care, precede the modern practice of philanthropy.
Denver: Well, let’s get a feel for one of them, and why not start with the Asian Women Giving Circle, which you started, as you said, 20 years– a million and a half, $2 million. Absolutely fantastic. How does it work? What are the dynamics of a giving circle? Maybe what are some of the challenges of running that giving circle?
Hali: Oh gosh. Okay. How much time do you have, Denver? So the first circle, so the first year, there were 10 of us. And we decided to set the bar kind of high, like so our give/ get in a way.
So each woman, it’s all women, we fund Asian American women, girls, families, and gender-expansive folks in New York City, which is where I live. I’m traveling right now, so I’m in a hotel. So we have been raising money and giving it away for 19 years at this point.
So we pool our money, and we decided that first year to set the bar kind of high. So each woman in the steering committee does her best to give or get, so raise or give $2,500 into the common pot. And we decided to set the bar a little bit high. And for some of us, just write a check. Some of us, fundraise our friends and family to get to that point, and we help each other to do that.
And we have an event where we can all come and that all counts towards our individual. We do our best to raise that money each. And we decided to set that bar kind of high because at that time, there were lots of nonprofits or there are lots of nonprofits in New York City, all of whom need board members who are not afraid of raising money.
So we figured this could be kind of like a training ground, like kind of in a sisterly, girlfriends kind of way. We could practice raising money for a cause that’s outside of us in a friendly, collegial, “come on, we can do this” kind of way. And that’s kind of how the giving circle was born.
“So if we can think about money as kind of this abstract thing that now has become kind of necessary in order to conduct modern life, there’s different ways to sort of play around with making it not the center, just a vehicle, a tool to get to where we want to go. And that’s part of, I think, what we’ve got to do.”
Denver: Is there a trick to getting people to get out there and raise money? I think it is the age-old problem in the sector, whether it be in the giving circle level or at a board level. People, I’ve always felt, Hali, that the reason galas are so successful, the only currency that we have in society that people feel comfortable about is, “Will you buy a table?”
But once you get beyond, “Will you buy a table?,” nobody likes to do it. I think they’re… I don’t know whether they’re afraid or whatever. How do you get around that?
Hali: It’s a real age-old problem, Denver. And I’m going to add, I think it’s even harder for women… like we were taught, a lot of us were taught from an early age: Don’t talk about money, sex, or politics. So money is like the first thing we’re not supposed to talk about. But in order to bring about the change that we want to see in our neighborhoods and towns, we’ve got to talk about money. Because it is one of the ways, not the only way, but one of the ways that change gets made.
And there’s a chapter in my book about how to talk about money. And I start with money, it’s like a concept. Like if you just Google, anyone who’s listening, just Google early forms of money, it’s like spices and pelts of fur and giant boulders in a South Pacific country. And then the evolution of banks came about so people wouldn’t have to carry around boulders and shells and forms of currency that weren’t recognized in the neighboring 10 miles away kind of place.
So if we can think about money as kind of this abstract thing that now has become kind of necessary in order to conduct modern life, there’s different ways to sort of play around with making it not the center, just a vehicle, a tool to get to where we want to go. And that’s part of, I think, what we’ve got to do.
Jen Risher, who started #HalfMyDAF. She and her husband were early Microsoft employees. They did not grow up wealthy, but they’ve become very wealthy in their young adulthood and into now. She has a beautiful book all about how you got to get comfortable with your wealth if you want to use it as a tool, whether it’s as an investor, or as a donor, or as a buyer of goods, or as a shopper or a restaurant-goer. Like however, right? You got to just kind of get over yourself a little bit and recognize it for the tool that it is.
Denver: Yeah. They’ve done some wonderful work, and I love their Half Your DAF.
Hali: # HalfMyDAF.
“It’s an epidemic in America, like we are, as a country, unhappy. We are lonely and unhappy.”
Denver: Yeah, #HalfMyDAF has really been a wonderful program.
You also write in the book about giving circles and why you might join one, but one that I never really thought about as much until I read it, your book, was loneliness. Talk a little bit about what’s going on in society about loneliness and how a giving circle maybe could help address that.
Hali: Gosh, I could have written a whole book just on that. And a lot of people have, like Robert Putnam’s work for the last 20 years, Bowling Alone, and others. Nicholas Kristof has written a beautiful series of essays in The Times about the kids he used to ride the school bus with in Oregon.
And he’s like my age… this is a while ago. And I think something like a quarter or maybe even a third of those kids in rural Oregon that he used to ride the school bus with, have died. And they died deaths of loneliness and despair, so suicide, substance abuse, alcoholism, et cetera.
It’s an epidemic in America, like we are, as a country, unhappy. We are lonely and unhappy. There’s unhappiness…
Denver: And getting unhappier.
Hali: And getting unhappier.
Denver: I think we’re 24th in the latest ranking. We’ve dropped to an all-time low.
Hali: Yes. We’ve dropped to 24… yeah, it’s terrible. And we all know people who are suffering in this way. And I’m not saying that giving circles are the only way, but they are a really good way to get people to get together to talk about things that are important to us, and to do one action together that moves towards cleaning up our street, like my block in Brooklyn cares about rats and trees.
This is not political. It’s literally cleaning up our streets because the rat population post-COVID has soared. So I can get together with my neighbors on my block, and we can talk about pruning trees with dead branches and figuring out trash collection. And also, it’s like there’s efficacy, which I don’t know if you have any mental health people in your world, but the feeling of efficacy, of being able to do something about something is part of being happy.
I can’t figure out rats and trees by myself on my block, but if I can get together with 10 of my neighbors, then we can make an effort to deal with getting trash receptacles, right? So giving circles are a perfect vehicle for getting together with neighbors… book groups… adult sports leagues.
I’ve heard of giving circles that start from like the hockey team that plays at midnight at Chelsea Piers. Groups that already are formed is kind of a good way to start a giving circle because you don’t have to start from scratch if you’re part of a book group, or a mommy or a daddy or parenting group, or an adult sports league, or a block association. So those are often good ways to start.
Denver: Yeah, sure. And they’re a relatively easy way to begin to address something like loneliness, which is so overwhelming to people who are lonely. You know, you want to take that first step. Join a giving circle. Start, that’s all you can do. Not the hardest step to take. Maybe a little challenge a bit to it, but you begin, and that’s how you get on the road to really getting social connection again.
Hali: Exactly. And there’s so many great examples, Denver, around the world, like cities, mayors around the city are recognizing that there are things they can do, like installing chatty benches in parks that encourage strangers to talk to one another. Putting up a bartering station, like bartering, like I’ll trade my KitchenAid mixer that I don’t use for your vacuum cleaner.
Like putting those in schools or elderly care facilities so that it brings people in to do something together that helps one another, but also, sidebar, gets people talking to the elderly folks in the community center.
There’s a great story, Denver. I love this so much. the Republic of Super Neighbors in France, there’s…
Denver: Okay.
Hali: …some guy, a neighbor, started this thing in a, I forget which arrondissement in Paris. But just getting all of his neighbors involved in this kind of thing, like trash collection, chatty benches, bartering stations. Come listen to Denver talk about nonprofits and the blah, blah. Come listen to this journalist talk about this and the blah, blah.
And this guy, they run a dinner once, one day every summer that takes up the whole boulevard of the primary street in their neighborhood, where like hundreds of people sit down at one long table and have a meal together. So it’s all the things from little to small to create a very walkable, connected, related neighborhood.
And I just think there’s such promise and hope in that if we can get to know each other in that kind of way to dig us out of the, excuse my French, shit show.
“It’s a big one… like we’re suffering, our country, right? So I feel like all of us, I want all of us to talk about it because the solutions, not to be so grand about, but the solutions to loneliness don’t have to be expensive. Like the antidote to loneliness is belonging.”
Denver: Yeah. Yeah. And also I think, particularly for people who are shy, having purpose makes it easier for them to talk. So if I have to meet someone and I’m shy, I don’t want to talk, I don’t like to talk about myself, I don’t like to do this, but if there’s a job we’re all doing, you can then begin to chat easily, and then it can go from there. And you can build bonds and relationships.
Hali: Totally. Can I say one more thing about loneliness?
Denver: Yeah. It’s a big one. I’m…
Hali: It’s a big one and it’s something we all Amer– like we’re suffering, our country, right? So I feel like all of us, I want all of us to talk about it because the solutions, not to be so grand about it, but the solutions to loneliness don’t have to be expensive.
Like the antidote to loneliness is belonging. And that is either inviting people in, like: Denver, Come over for dinner with someone I don’t know, and I can meet someone new. And then I can also be invited by you. So it’s kind of a two-way street, like being open to being invited and also inviting.
And if you play it forward, like my giving circle, like I said, we’re turning 20, during COVID, I don’t know if you remember, but there were those awful shootings of Asian women, Asian American women in Atlanta who were working in the spa/massage industry. And at that point, my giving circle was, I don’t know, 15, 16 years old. That was a community.
That was the first we got together on Zoom. It was during COVID, and we just cried. Like we understood intimately all the intersections of race and xenophobia and immigration and gender and class, and the sexification of female Asian bodies, et cetera. Like we understood all of those toxic collisions that were coming together in that moment.
And so I think like we’re 15 years into this project of building relationships with one another and building community with one another, and building efficacy with one another. So if you pay it forward 15 years in, then not only can this kind of community of a giving circle be a balm, but it can also kind of be lifesaving.
Like these were the first calls when Trump won the first time. We were the first calls when those spa shootings happened. We got shoved at Trader Joe’s. We got told to go home during COVID… and the anti-Asian hate spike that happened in New York at that time. So there’s like the beautiful part, and then there’s also like the helping each other part.
Denver: Yeah. Yeah. But it’s also the part that when something bad happens, this is when we circle the wagons, this is the group. This is where we start. We start with one another. Right.
Let’s pick up on that a little bit. Your report, Hali, philanthropy always sounds like someone else, a profile of high-net-worth people of color, and that resulted from 113 interviews that you did of people of color who faced racial and ethnic bias. What were some of the takeaways from that report? And maybe was there a story of one of those conversations you had that has really stuck with you?
Hali: Oh my god, so many. We actually interviewed 150 people and…
Denver: Oh, okay.
Hali: …113 stories got themed and condensed into that report. First of all, it was a total blast to do and an honor. I got to go around and interview people of color around their wealth.
So takeaways are: they’re not that different from wealthy people who are white, in some ways. A lot of them made their own money. A lot of them care a lot about faith place, faith giving, hospitals and higher education. Harvard, Stanford came out too often as recipients of some of the largesse of these folks.
And so there are some similarities, like I don’t want to say that they’re totally different from just wealthy people in general in America. But some things that stand out to me are: Every single person I interviewed had personally experienced racism, discrimination, or bias based on the color of their skin, their accent, their country of origin, their name, whatever.
So they talked about that and how that influences where they give and how they give, and it does. So let’s say they want to give to Harvard because they went there, and they saw that all the doors, so many doors opened for them by virtue of their going there. They would be more likely to set up a fund for kids who are from an inner city like they were, to get funding to go to… or a first-generation college kid, say. They might be more likely to do that. So that stands out to me.
They were also, in general, very averse to this, “Bootstraps is bullshit.” is a direct quote from one of the guys I interviewed. His family comes from Jamaica, and he’s become a banker. And he and his mom are investing in properties, and they’re doing really well financially. But he was the first to say, “I’m good at what I do. I’m decently smart. I’m not like extra smart. My sister’s smarter than me. She’s a nurse. She makes a fraction of what I make.”
He doesn’t draw a line between his income and his value and his worth. And he talked up the mentors, the coaches, the aunties and uncles, some of whom are not blood-related, his mother, his sister. He talked about so many people who helped him get to where he is and continue to help him, and they’re continuing to build wealth together as a family even now. So that idea of “bootstraps is bullshit” is a theme for me.
And then stories-wise, I tell one of them in my book. I’m not going to use his real name. I call him Jorge in my book. He grew up in the northeast, but pretty poor. And there were periods of time when he and his seven family members lived in a station wagon together because they were periodically without a home.
And he talked about this woman who he called an Auntie Mame, and I think she was someone who worked at his school, but she saw something in this kid, Jorge, and she’s the one who taught him how to read a menu at a restaurant. They would go out once in a while. And he said to me that the restaurants he’d been to before, the menu was up on the wall. It wasn’t like a thing that you read.
So she taught him about that, and she planted in this kid, and he described himself kind of as like a brat, a smart brat. But she planted the idea of this kid that he might go to college, that he might have a life in front of him that was different from what he was seeing. And sure enough, this kid went to college.
He’s giving away at that time $70,000 a year or around that amount every year away, politically and charitably. And he and his partner have raised and have fostered many kids, and he’s really paying it forward. And he said to me that what he learned from his experience, and he’s the only one in his family who got out of that station wagon figuratively, and got out and built a different kind of life.
And he said that woman, this Auntie Mame in his life, was able to see the… in every kid, there’s a king; and in every king, there is a kid. And this woman was able to see both the kid and the king in him.
Denver: Wow.
Hali: And I will never forget that story and that man and that thing. And if we could see that in the people around us, the kid and the king in everyone, think about how that changes just the way we walk through the world.
Denver: Oh, the possibilities, infinite! Absolutely! Yeah.
Hali, turning this vision of yours, into a book, The Big We, yeah, I’ve done a couple. That’s not an easy task at all. It really is hard. What was the trickiest piece to wrestle down onto a page, and when did you think… and how did you know: I think I got it right?
Hali: I’m not sure I got it right, Denver. I hope I got it right.
Denver: I know. I think what somebody said once is they said a book is never done, it’s just due, and that’s essentially what it gets down to.
Hali: I think that’s right. The cutting…
Denver: You could go on forever.
Hali: I could go on forever. And if we keep talking, you’ll see, you’ll just say, Hali, shut up now. You’ve gone on too long. The cutting room floor is tragic in this case, and also in the donors of color research and build. The stories that didn’t make it in, it’s terrible.
I loved the writing, and I loved the story gathering and the pulling of the themes. I spent a lot of time in New Mexico with my mom and dad who are 89 and 94. And when I’m there, I have no life. So they go to bed at eight o’clock. So…
Denver: They stay up that late.
Hali: Yeah, exactly. Well, yeah, then I can stay up a little later than that.
So I did get a lot of writing done in the half a year that I spent with them because I go back and forth, because I want to spend as much time with them as I can and help out as I can. So that helped. On the weekends, I could work there. Whereas in New York where I normally live, my time is much more taken.
Editing sucked… as trying to… and I had a really great editor at Zando and I also have a wonderful agent, Maggie at Aevitas, and she’s a really good editor. So they made me defend the stories that I wanted to keep, and that’s a painful but necessary partner to have, is the person that kindly, but gently makes you defend why you need to keep.
I trimmed the billionaire section of my book by like a hundred pages.
Denver: Wow.
Hali: Because that part was fun to write. They’re like, Hali, this is not a book about billionaires. It’s supposed to be about everyone else. So that was a helpful reminder. So those two things, I guess, like I had the luxury of time because I spent time with my elderly parents, not at my hometown. And then I also travel a lot. So rather than watch rom-coms, which is my usual default on airplane rides, I made myself write. So that was another tip.
Denver: Yeah. That’s another tip to keep in mind.
Well, I think The Big We really turns philanthropy upside down because you don’t talk about those billionaires and galas the way we think of philanthropy. You stand it on their head. And what’s one shift that you hope people will see in how giving is done and what a philanthropist is? And what philanthropy is?
Hali: Thank you for that, Denver, and I want to pull out a bit before I go back in. So if people can remember this inauguration of Donald Trump, the second term, the one that just happened in January, three people were sitting in row two right behind Donald Trump as he got inaugurated: Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, and Jeff Bezos. They’re three billionaires. Those three individuals own as much wealth as the 50% of Americans in the bottom 50 percentile of America.
Denver: Three, three people. Yeah.
Hali: Three people own as much wealth as 50% of Americans. That is 170 million people. So America’s like 340 million people right now, ish.
Denver: That’s about right. Yeah.
Hali: So half of America is 170 million people, and three men sitting behind Donald Trump on the dais own as much wealth as 170 million Americans. That is wrong. It’s unsustainable, and it’s undemocratic. So even though the first third of my book right here, The Big We...
Denver: Yeah.
Hali: …is a critique.
Denver: You’re good at this. You’ve been doing this. I can see.
Hali: Well, I’m trying. I’m not great at this market. Here it is.
Denver: Probably a little bit closer to the head, I think is…
Hali: Oh, okay. Here we go.
Denver: There you go. Yeah.
Hali: You can buy it anywhere books are sold. Go to a bookshop.
Denver: That’s right. Yeah. Like the lady with the tie. Do you know what I mean? Just right up…
Hali: Yes. I just need to have like nicer nails, red nails or something. So the first third of my book, I critique billionaire-led, rich-guy-knows-best. It’s usually a guy.
Denver: Yeah, it is.
Hali: And knows best philanthropy. I critique that in the first third, and it’s kind of a fun thing to critique, and lots of people have critiqued it, including Anand Giridharadas, et cetera, Bob Reich, et cetera. Great books. But I didn’t want to stay there because my heart is with the rest of us.
Denver: That’s right.
Hali: But even as I critique billionaire philanthropy, and I nickname him, Big Phil, it’s a critique of the way our federal government is going right now. Like do we want to move… the question, I think, in front of all of us right now in the US is this idea of our five T’s: time, talent, treasure, testimony, and ties.
And one of the things I talk about in the book is that giving circles are a great way for people to use all of their five T’s in order to make their communities more free, more fair, more joyful, more opportunity equal for all, right? Do we want to move all of our five T’s towards our communities, or do we want to move all of our five T’s towards these three billionaires who are currently running amok through our federal public goods and services in order to enrich themselves and their billionaire friends?
I mean, that is literally the choice. And I think philanthropy is a microcosm of the larger dilemma that confronts all of us right here, right now, today. And I think it’s really important that we remember that it is people power; it is civically-engaged citizens.
Like our system only works when it’s citizens, which is you and me, and you and you and you and you and you all around us know enough to get engaged, know enough to get educated, get engaged, and link arms with our sisters and brothers and fellow and sister travelers, in order to make our communities more free of trash or whatever the thing is. Like start there.
Denver: Yeah.
Hali: And then, that leads to more and more engagement. It just needs to happen on a massive scale in order to make sure our system works for us and isn’t reoriented towards the billionaires that were on the stage in January.
Denver: What’s your commentary about what’s going on right now as it relates to philanthropy, how philanthropy is stepping up to this moment, or let’s say stepping back from this moment? And are you hopeful in terms of what philanthropy is going to do in really energizing the public in a way that perhaps we haven’t really seen just yet?
Hali: Well, I don’t know. My magic wand is big at this, like it starts with public education from age three or four. I don’t think… I’m not sure if my 8-year-old niece knows what the separation of powers is in government. I don’t know if my 8-year-old…
Denver: If there is one.
Hali: I don’t think… well, there’s going to not be one if it keeps going.
Denver: Yeah. The way it’s going. Yeah.
Hali: I don’t know if my 8-year-old niece knows about the separation of church and state. You know, like do you remember when I was a kid, there was that Schoolhouse Rock! and there was like, “I’m just a bill, sitting here on Capitol Hill.”
Denver: Oh yeah.
Hali: Like there was a cartoon about how bills get made and a legislative process, like my magic wand goes to that… like preschool and early education, because at public education, it takes up an educated populace to be citizens of a democracy. And I think it’s a concerted, on purpose effort to dismantle that among other public goods and services in order to bring about a more oligarchic, authoritarian form of government.
And philanthropy has a role to play, but it’s not as big a weapon or a tool in the toolbox as we think it is. So it’s got to play with public sector and private sector actors, I think, and massive civic action, massive people just getting involved in getting organized and getting mad, and then getting activated. I mean, I’m a glass-half-full kind of person for sure.
Denver: You are for sure.
Hali: I am, for sure.
Denver: Yeah.
Hali: But it’s not easy in this moment for us glass half-full types. But the alternative is capitulation, and that’s not an option, so we got to try.
Denver: Yeah. Yeah. I think that the time for regrouping is long gone. Okay? It’s over. We’ve regrouped. Now, let’s go.
Hali: And we have groups.
Denver: My magic wand though is philanthropy, in that I would love in my public schools to have purpose and philanthropy taught at the age of six.
Hali: I love that.
Denver: I don’t think… you cannot get people purpose-driven and philanthropically driven as adults; you have to really do it when they’re 6, 7, 8 years old and probably even more than philanthropy– purpose. I think if we could put that in the schools, I think it would make a huge difference in society.
Hali: I love that idea. And philanthropy could fund it, like philanthropy could fund kind of an odd but really important thing like that.
Philanthropy has a role to play, for sure. And philanthropy is a form of civic engagement, and that is what we’re talking about, and that is what I want my buddies who work in the field to always remember, like: What is our role as people who work in the nonprofit and philanthropy sectors to build a civically engaged population, a civically engaged citizenry? That’s what we could be funding right now.
In addition to, as we talked about before you were recording, like there’s some emergency fires that need to be addressed. So one of the things I’ve been talking about with my friends who are philanthropic advisors is if people are freaking out and they don’t know what to do– and there’s a lot of overwhelm and anxiety right now– one easy thing that I think all of us can do is just call our favorite local nonprofit and just give them some money for legal aid.
A lot of nonprofits, big and small, are facing legal bills that they didn’t know they would be facing. Just call them and give them some money that they can use for general operating support… or if they need to have that many earmarked for legal expenses because sometimes that helps.
Denver: That’s a brilliant idea. It really is.
Hali: Give them a thousand bucks or $500, whatever you can do.f
Denver: Yeah, that is great. And particularly after what the administration said the other day, that they’re going to fight it back on frivolous lawsuits. So essentially, we can do anything we want, and if you take issue with it, we’re going to call it frivolous. So you’re in the middle of something which nobody expected. Nobody is prepared for bills along those lines in order to contend with that.
Hali: No. And none of them can afford it.
Denver: None of them can afford it.
Hali: It’s ironic because of course, they’ve been the most prolific, frivolous lawsuit person.
Denver: Sue, sue, sue.
Hali: Yeah.
Denver: Every drop of the hat. I wanted to pick up one thing you mentioned before about your mom and dad, and you have a really interesting family story, surviving wars in Korea. And you too, your grandmother coming over here and helping others in the US, I mean, with such rich generosity.
Tell us a little bit about how you got to where you’re at right now through the stories of your family.
Hali: Thank you for asking that. And congratulations, I understand you’re a new grandpa.
Denver: Thank you.
Hali: So this idea of legacy is such a profound one in our sector, our field, and you and I are incredibly lucky that we get to work in this arena of giving back and philanthropy and helping others because it’s all about legacy. And how lucky are we that we get to think about this every day?
So I will bring my grandfather into the room who I never got to meet. So my grandfather is Hahn Chi Chin and he’s my mom’s father. And he got a PhD in philosophy from the University of Southern California in the early 1900s, and then went right back to Korea and taught at Ewha, which is a big women’s university in Korea.
And then he had the misfortune of being born during a time during Japanese colonization of the Korean peninsula. This was a time when Koreans had to take Japanese surnames. It was illegal to speak Korean. My grandmother took her kids out of school so they wouldn’t be forced to speak Japanese and punished for slipping and speaking Korean.
It was a time when this imperial force was really trying to erase the culture and people of my homeland, even though I never lived there. My grandfather became a freedom fighter. He was imprisoned, tortured, and nearly killed by the Japanese imperial army for the sin of being a Korean cultural scholar.
And then five short years later, the Korean War started and he was taken away and forcibly marched to the north by what became the North Korean army, and never heard from again.
Denver: Oh wow.
Hali: Same sin of being a freedom fighter and a Korean cultural scholar. Left my grandmother alone to raise six children, the oldest daughter of whom was my mom.
So even though I never knew my grandfather, I hope and pray that one tiny particle of his fight and principle and values and kindness live in me and my brother and my cousins, and live on in my children.
But how can I not think of him and where I come from as I get to do the work that I get to do, which is to drive more resources to the people leading movements for more fairness and justice in this country, right?
My grandmother was a badass, feminist, cranky matriarch, and she died at the age of 97. So I can’t even imagine how she, as a refugee, took care of and supported her six kids. I can’t even imagine what that would be like. But I think about them a lot, even though one of them I never knew and one of them helped raise me. So thank you for asking.
Denver: Yeah. Yeah. Well, she sounds like a tough old bird, I’ll tell you that.
Hali: She was a tough old bird.
Denver: Yeah. And I can see how those stories really drive and inform the work that you’re doing today. So…
Hali: If I’m lucky, they do, right? And in hard moments, we have to remember on whose shoulders we stand to do this work.
Hali: And then playing it forward, Denver, like this was a really moving part of the interviews to build the donors of color research and network build. We got to, just like this, conversations. Usually in person, in living rooms. It was before COVID. Just like, on whose shoulders do you stand to do this work? And playing it forward, what kind of ancestor do you want to be…
Denver: Yeah.
Hali: …for the generations ahead of you about whom you can only dream?
Like how lucky are we that we get to sit with that? Maybe not every day, but regularly? And then how does that kind of vision or values or like, you know, the oomph underneath it inform or give us strength, or inspire or drive or carrot and stick to fight for the things that we want to fight for?
“I think the future of philanthropy is collective. The future of philanthropy is not, I hope, billionaires telling us what is best for us… It’s people in communities deciding for themselves what is best for them, raising the money to do what is best for them, with the support and help of people who are outside of their communities necessarily, because not all of us can live everywhere at the same time. But the drivers of the change are the collective. That’s my dream.”
Denver: It’s a great frame. It’s thinking of your eulogy at your funeral, and what is it going to say? And if you keep that in mind on a day-to-day basis, maybe your behavior is going to be a little bit different than it otherwise might.
Finally, Hali, it’s 2035, 10 years in giving circles. I mean, they’re everywhere, thanks to The Big We, of course. What’s one wild dream for philanthropy that you have for then that we might not even be able to contemplate today?
Hali: I want this idea of moving from a me to a we frame to be in everyday language. Like every decision point: Can I reframe this decision point from an I/ me position to what is a better… what is a we position? And it’s not going to lead to the right answer every time, but I want it to be a consideration every time.
I think the future of philanthropy is collective. The future of philanthropy is not, I hope, billionaires telling us what is best for us. The future of philanthropy is collective. It’s people in communities deciding for themselves what is best for them, raising the money to do what is best for them, with the support and help of people who are outside of their communities necessarily, because not all of us can live everywhere at the same time. But the drivers of the change are the collective. That’s my dream.
Denver: Well stated. The book is The Big We: How Giving Circles Unlock Generosity, Strengthen Community, and Make Change. And the message is: The new default is no longer “me,” it is “we.”
Thanks so much for being here today, Hali. It was a real delight to have you on the program.
Hali: Thank you for having me, Denver.
To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com
