Organizations collect enormous amounts of evidence: surveys, evaluations, dashboards, consultant reports. We treat all of that information as proof that decisions are well informed.
It may prove nothing of the sort.
A board can review the same disappointing numbers for years. A CEO can commission research that simply confirms the strategy already chosen. A team can explain away findings that don’t fit what it already believes. Nothing is hidden, and nothing is ignored. The information is simply unable to move the decision.
That suggests a very different way to measure whether an organization actually values evidence:
-
Don’t count the reports—count the reversals.
-
What did you stop doing?
-
Where did the money move?
-
Which assumption got abandoned?
-
Whose mind actually changed?
If those questions are hard to answer, more measurement isn’t the fix. You likely have plenty of evidence already. What you lack is evidence with authority.
The next time someone presents important findings, don’t stop at what did we learn? Ask what you’re going to do differently because you learned it.
When was the last time evidence made you do something you didn’t already want to do?
