We assume the person who made an important decision is best positioned to evaluate how it turned out. They know what they were trying to accomplish, why they chose that person or strategy, and the context better than anyone else.

All true. But they also carry something nobody else does: their own judgment is now part of what’s being evaluated.

  • A board chair who personally recruited the CEO.
  • A CEO who championed an executive everyone else questioned.
  • A donor who made an unusually large bet.

As evidence mounts that the decision may have been wrong, reconsidering it requires answering two questions instead of one: is this still working? and was I wrong? Those two are far harder to keep separate than they sound. The longer a decision survives, the more its creator has built around it, defended it, and staked other choices on it.

Eventually, evidence against the choice starts to feel like evidence against the person who made it. That is exactly when independent judgment becomes most valuable—and hardest to get.

For anything consequential, decide in advance who gets to reconsider it if you become too invested in having been right. Taking responsibility for a decision is good leadership; recognizing that the responsibility itself can become a bias is rarer, and better.

Who would you trust to tell you that you were wrong about something you’ve defended for years?

Share This: