A funder once told a community group I was advising that he would consider their work proven when they produced the kind of evidence his board recognized. Randomized, controlled, expensive. The group did the most effective work in their neighborhood and could not produce a study like that in a hundred years. The people they served already knew it worked. That was not the kind of knowing that counted.
Every funder eventually has to answer a question that sounds technical and is actually moral. What would convince you that this works? The answer feels like a matter of rigor, of being hardheaded rather than sentimental, so leaders reach for the most authoritative-sounding standard available and hold everyone they fund to it. What took me years to understand is that the question is never neutral. The standard of proof you choose is also a decision about whose knowledge you will honor and whose you will quietly throw away.
When you insist on one narrow kind of evidence, you are not only raising the bar for truth.
You are deciding that the people who can produce that kind of evidence deserve funding and the people who cannot do not. And those two groups are almost never sorted by who is doing the most good.
There is a real failure on the other side, the program that resists all evaluation because accountability is inconvenient. The answer is not to abandon rigor. It is to refuse to mistake a single method for rigor itself.
The most serious funders I know ask for evidence and stay curious about its limits in the same breath. They want to know whether something works, and they remember that the people closest to the work know things no trial was ever built to capture.
So a question worth sitting with. Whose knowledge does your standard of proof quietly exclude? And is it possible the people you are not funding are the ones who actually know what works?
