Bonterra CEO shares why charitable giving has stagnated and how AI could unlock unprecedented growth

A Personal Mission Born from Frustration
Scott Brighton’s wife is the executive director of a nonprofit. He sees firsthand how she and her small team are brilliant at their mission but perpetually stretched thin, trying to scale their impact with minimal resources. It’s a scene Brighton knows intimately, one that crystallized his thinking about the sector’s biggest challenge.

The reality, Brighton explains, is that nonprofits are unbelievably resource constrained. He notes that a frugal for profit company might operate at 35% margins, while a nonprofit is expected to run at the equivalent of an 80% margin.

As CEO of Bonterra, Brighton leads a technology company that provides solutions to funders and nonprofits, including about half of the Fortune 100 corporations. His boldest initiative, however, is not just about building better software; it’s about fundamentally changing how America gives.

The Stubborn Growth Problem
For 50 years, charitable giving has grown at about 2% a year, roughly the same rate as the country’s GDP. This has happened even as Americans have become seven times wealthier per capita and nonprofits have adopted new technologies. Brighton observed how stubborn that growth trajectory had been and decided to focus his company’s vision on a new goal. “We want to orient everything that we’re doing around how we
bend that curve,” he says.

His solution is to help increase giving from about 2.5% to 3% of GDP by 2033. The math is staggering. Compounded over a decade, that increase would generate over $580 billion in additional funding, enough to meaningfully address huge challenges like homelessness and community violence in major cities across America.

Building a Connection Engine
Bonterra’s strategy rests on a simple observation: both sides of the giving equation struggle with the same problem. Funders can’t find the right nonprofits among two million options. Nonprofits can’t identify aligned funders.

“When I talk to our funders, they’re like: Our biggest problem is finding the right nonprofits to work with,” Brighton explains. “When I talk to nonprofits, they say: Our biggest problem is finding the right funders that are interested in sustaining our mission. We’re trying to bring both of them together.” But connection is only half the battle. Bonterra’s innovation lies in what happens next, using AI powered tools that amplify both sides’ capacity to build and maintain relationships.

The Science of Asking Right

One breakthrough came from analyzing 500,000 daily nonprofit transactions to develop “Optimized Ask” technology. The premise is Fundraising 101: ask for too much and you scare donors away; ask for too little and you leave money on the table.

“There’s a magic number to ask for,” Brighton says. His company’s technology looks at behavioral and demographic data to determine the optimal amount. The result is powerful. “On average, a nonprofit is yielding an 11% increase,” he notes. “If we look at the 11% increase, that actually gets you halfway there to our 3% by 39;33.” The data also revealed surprising donor behaviors. Based on Bonterra’s 2025 Impact Report, many so called lapsed donors are not actually disengaged. “Fully 20% of the donor base is giving outside that sort of normal sustainer window,” Brighton says. Nonprofits that treat these supporters as lost causes after a few months risk undermining valuable relationships.

The Resilience Factor

Perhaps the most surprising insight from Bonterra’s data is the power of persistence. While 63% of nonprofits give up after one unsuccessful grant application, success typically comes after just 1.24 attempts. “It doesn’t actually take that much more before that no becomes yes,” Brighton explains. “The more resilient you are, the more it impacts your fundraising. Now it’s hard because of the resource constraints.”

AI as the Great Equalizer
Brighton’s three year vision centers on “agentic AI,” which involves proactive digital agents that can observe, suggest, and execute tasks. He imagines an AI grant writer that scours opportunities, identifies good matches, drafts applications, and tracks submissions.

He reflects on his wife’s nonprofit, which has two or three people. “I think in the future there’s effectively going to be two or three humans, but then another 20 agentic grant writers and individual giving fundraisers and whatnot.”

This is not about replacing humans. It is about democratizing the personalized attention that today only major donors receive, allowing human fundraisers to manage the big relationships while AI cultivates smaller dollar donors.

The Generational Shift
Bonterra’s corporate clients are already seeing changes in how employees want to give. Gen Z workers prefer supporting hyperlocal, grassroots organizations. They care more about solving problems than organizational prestige.

“They’re less interested in doing things like giving to the United Way,” Brighton observes, “but less about those sort of large nonprofits, and more about those specific, hyperlocal opportunities, where they’re feeling like their activities, volunteerism, money can make a difference.”

The Road to 3%
Brighton’s confidence in achieving the 3% goal stems from convergent trends: better donor matching, AI amplified capacity, optimized asks, and a generation that values direct impact. “This isn’t about trying to drive efficiency among humans,” he says. “This is about amplifying capacity, and that is really going to help.”

For nonprofits ready to join this transformation, Brighton’s advice is simple. He suggests they get a structure for collecting good, clean data. “Having good data as these new AI applications come online, is going to be the secret sauce to enable everything.”

The vision is ambitious, but Brighton has seen what is possible when resource constrained organizations get the right tools. In just over eight years, American giving could double. The question is not whether the technology exists, but whether the sector is ready to embrace it.

Learn more about Bonterra’s 3% by 2033 initiative at bonterratech.com


To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com 

Share This: