Customized Strategies, Not Cookie Cutter Plans

As Marts&Lundy approaches its 100th anniversary, CEO Doug Stewart makes it clear that the firm’s success hasn’t come from off the shelf solutions. “We take a one size fits one approach,” he says. “We do not offer off the shelf solutions. And we really get to know our clients intimately and partner with them as collaborators, and we really offer very customized solutions for where they are.” This highly tailored approach is matched by the firm’s culture of employee ownership, where everyone, from analysts to senior consultants, has a vested interest in client success.

That ownership culture isn’t just a feel good story. It’s a performance driver. “Everyone just feels like it is a family, and they all have a stake in the future of the firm,” Stewart explains. “It has created a phenomenal culture. It’s a very collegial, mutually supportive culture.”

Campaigns in Uncertain Times

In a time of economic uncertainty, policy whiplash, and digital disruption, Stewart says the most common question from nonprofit leaders is: “Should we move forward with our campaign?” His answer is a resounding yes. “Philanthropy is incredibly durable and resilient,” he notes, pointing out that giving has historically held steady or even increased during downturns. The key is to stay focused on mission and long term value. “We are reminding our clients that they’re in this for the long term,” he says, “whether that’s an eight year campaign, or the next 40 years of their delivering on their mission.”

To sustain momentum during long campaigns, Stewart advises introducing new priorities, creating excitement with fresh initiatives, and bringing in new volunteer leadership to energize the campaign midstream.

Rethinking Donor Engagement
When it comes to working with boards, Stewart encourages a shift in mindset. He notes that “really high functioning boards” are those where members “accept shared responsibility for philanthropy.” Even board members who are hesitant to ask for money can play critical roles, such as vetting fundraising priorities, advocating publicly, and engaging potential donors. “There’s a lot that an engaged board member can do short of asking for money.”

That same mindset shift applies to donors themselves, particularly in the era of mega gifts. “These major donors have become investors, and they expect results and dividends,” Stewart observes. That means metrics matter, but not just the obvious ones. He explains that institutions must look beyond wealth to differentiate between passive feelings and active involvement. The key is tracking behavior.

“Attachment is passive. Engagement is active,” he explains. He urges leaders to go beyond “mere metrics of attachment, and looking at metrics of engagement.”

Unleashing the Middle of the Pyramid

One of the biggest missed opportunities Stewart sees? The middle of the donor pyramid. “There is treasure in those hills,” he says. While most nonprofits focus on either mega donors or annual giving, they’re ignoring donors capable of giving $25,000 to $100,000. “Most of our clients are doing a particularly bad job in that, and we are counseling them to spend more time on mid pyramid strategies.”

He points to his own experience as board chair of a local music nonprofit. Once they painted a picture of what a $50,000 gift could achieve, such as music scholarships, school outreach, and masterclasses, donors stepped up. They always had the capacity to give more, he says, but “they just didn’t know we had the capacity to use bigger gifts.”

Boards, AI, and the Culture of Philanthropy

Stewart is both optimistic and measured when it comes to AI. He sees tremendous potential in predictive modeling to help institutions identify major donor prospects from massive databases. But he draws a line at virtual gift officers. “Donor interactions are inherently a relationship business,” he says. “People can do that better than robots.”

At the end of the day, Stewart offers a piece of advice that not every consultant is willing to voice: “Philanthropy has to be one of the core pillars of your organization. It cannot be seen as frosting on the cake. It cannot be seen as the development director’s job. It has to be one of the core pillars of the organization, not only for the CEO, but for the chief financial officer, for the chief marketing officer, for everyone in the C suite.”


To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com 

Share This: