If you’re a nonprofit leader, you know the feeling. It’s 2 AM, and you’re lying awake wondering how you’ll make payroll next month. You’ve applied for grants, reached out to donors, maybe even hired more development staff—but somehow you’re still stuck in what Kevin Brown calls the “nonprofit starvation cycle.”
Brown, author of Fundable & Findable: The Brand-New Way to Fix Your Nonprofit Fundraising, recently joined me on The Business of Giving podcast to share a counterintuitive truth: more fundraising doesn’t fix fundraising. Brand does.
The Brand-First Revolution
For decades, the nonprofit sector has operated under a straightforward but flawed assumption: when you need more money, you fundraise more. But after years of working with underfunded organizations, Brown discovered something fundamental—this approach keeps organizations small, invisible, and stuck.
“Brand is the engine, and fundraising is the fuel,” Brown explains. “Brand is the soil, and fundraising is the water. Brand is the foundation; fundraising is the roof. There are so many connection points between brand and fundraising, but at the end of the day, brand does have to precede your fundraising.”
Importantly, he’s not talking about logos or color palettes. Brown distinguishes between brand (your identity, clarity, and strategy) and branding (your visual and verbal expression). Too many organizations obsess over the latter while neglecting the former.
Your Theory of Change Is What You’re Selling
One of Brown’s most memorable reframes is this: “Your theory of change is what donors are buying.” Unless you’re a social enterprise with a tangible product, your theory of change is the product. It’s what you’re offering funders.
Yet nonprofits often stumble in one of three ways:
• They don’t have a theory of change—or it’s buried in a forgotten document.
• The theory is incomplete, missing key components like a clear problem statement or
compelling vision.
• It’s only used internally, not as a communication and fundraising tool.
Brown’s complete framework boils down to three fundamental questions:
1. Why do we exist? (the problem)
2. What do we do? (your unique solution)
3. Where are we going? (the result or outcome)
The Alignment Gap
If you ask 20 staff members at a nonprofit why the organization exists, you might get 15 different answers. That’s a red flag.
“Leaders are repeaters,” Brown says. “It’s critical for us as nonprofit leaders to constantly reinforce: ‘Hey team, remember, this is why we exist.’”
His advice is practical: get your theory of change down on paper, then embed it into everyday internal language—staff meetings, board discussions, decision-making, and onboarding. Clarity should never be assumed. It must be rehearsed and reinforced.
The Diversification Trap
One of Brown’s most counterintuitive findings pushes back against a widely held belief: that diversified funding is the gold standard. While this model may help early-stage organizations survive, research shows it becomes a constraint on growth.
“Diversified funding is a nonprofit nemesis,” Brown explains. “We choose that word ‘nemesis’ very carefully because we’re not saying it’s bad. We’re saying: it’s good for a while, but then you get trapped.”
He cites a 40-year study by The Bridgespan Group of hundreds of thousands of nonprofits. Those that reached scale did so by focusing on a single type of funding—not a single funder. For example, instead of chasing foundations and government contracts and small donors, organizations that scale double down on one category and tailor their strategy accordingly.
The Mindset Shift Leaders Must Make
Brown sees a consistent stumbling block among nonprofit executives: they remain too embedded in daily program delivery to build a scalable organization.
“Most nonprofit leaders are doctors and lawyers and teachers,” he says. “They didn’t come from an MBA background. So they focus where they’re most comfortable—on the frontlines. But to scale, you need to work on the business, not just in the business.”
That shift means stepping back from operations and becoming your organization’s best
storyteller, chief fundraiser, and lead brand ambassador. It’s not easy—but it’s essential.
Simple Tools to Get Unstuck
Feeling overwhelmed? Brown offers two quick but powerful exercises any leader can implement:
The One-Sentence Theory of Change: “Because [why], we work [where] to help [who] do [what] [how] by [when].”
The One-Sentence Marketing Strategy: “Unlike [other organizations], we are [three unique qualities] and we focus on [these channels] to reach [this goal].”
These fill-in-the-blank templates can bring sharp clarity to funding conversations—and start the journey toward being more fundable and findable.
Fundraising Is Just Good Communication
A final surprise for Brown was how much of fundraising isn’t really fundraising—it’s just communications.
“The main two reasons that donors don’t give again is that number one, they weren’t told how their gift was used, and number two, they didn’t feel thanked,” he says. “That literally is just communications.”
Donor retention, stewardship, and cultivation don’t require advanced development theory. They require clarity, consistency, and common sense.
Looking Ahead
With major donors like USAID scaling back and global uncertainty rising, Brown’s message feels more urgent than ever. Even organizations that haven’t relied on public sector funding must now sharpen their story, clarify their uniqueness, and compete for increasingly limited philanthropic dollars.
“You do have to show why you’re unique,” Brown notes. “Why should a funder give you potentially limited budget relative to another?”
The future won’t be won by working harder at fundraising—it will be won by building a bold, clear, compelling brand that makes your organization not only fundable, but findable.
To listen to the full interview or read the transcript, just click here.
To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com
