With donors declining every year since 2019, how do nonprofits survive? In a compelling episode of The Business of Giving, Josh Birkholz, CEO of BWF, shares a bold solution: embrace vulnerability and mission to ignite donor loyalty. With economic uncertainty and federal funding cuts looming in 2025, Josh’s insights—rooted in BWF’s 40-year legacy of innovation—offer nonprofits a lifeline. His message? Authentic connections and purpose-driven asks can reverse troubling trends and fuel resilience.

A Legacy of Bold Partnership

BWF’s journey began with game-changers like the Statue of Liberty restoration and the first Giving Day at Florida State, sparking a global trend. Josh, a data science pioneer and BeneFactors co-author, drives this legacy forward. “We don’t know more, we know different,” he says, emphasizing BWF’s role as a collaborative partner walking alongside nonprofits. This empathy-first ethos sets BWF apart, whether it’s building AI-powered donor pipelines or boosting alumni giving, proving small ideas can ignite massive impact.

Vulnerability as a Superpower

Josh’s standout insight is that vulnerability builds trust. During the pandemic, BWF guided a university to host virtual donor meetups, turning isolation into community and lifting giving by 15% when campaigns faltered. “When things aren’t going well, saying ‘This is a challenge’ brings supporters closer,” Josh explains. Data backs this: donors who connect with other donors increase giving by 23%.

Mission-Driven Boldness

With donor participation down 20% over a decade, Josh urges nonprofits to reclaim their “why.” Top fundraisers, who raise 80% of dollars, succeed because donors believe they’d give the same gifts they ask for, per BeneFactors. This mission-driven esteem fueled Hope College’s Hope Challenge, a creative campaign that disrupted traditional fundraising. Josh advises pitching “moonshot” ideas to high-net-worth donors seeking significance. A California university, with BWF’s guidance, reframed its cross-cultural program as a global model, landing 8-figure gifts.

Navigating 2025 with AI and Resilience

Josh sees opportunity in 2025’s challenges, like the $84 trillion wealth transfer to Millennials. He recommends investing in base-level donors, citing the Generosity Commission’s roadmap (generositycommission.org) to rebuild the declining everyday donor base. AI is also key: “It learns from our dataset to find donors,” Josh says, comparing it to the internet’s early days. But he warns against cutting operations: “Support staff free fundraisers to raise more, or you lose capacity.”

A Call to Act

Josh’s vision is clear: vulnerability and mission can transform fundraising. Nonprofits can thrive in 2025 by fostering authentic bonds and bold ideas that offer donors meaning. Listen to the full episode at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com, share your bold fundraising story on X @TheBizofGive, or explore BWF’s tools at bwf.com to unlock your potential.

To listen to the full interview or read the transcript, just click here.


To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com 

Share This: