One of the most dangerous habits in leadership is assuming that a good outcome proves you made a good decision. It doesn’t.
Robert Rosenkranz, author of The Stoic Capitalist, made a distinction that deserves much wider use. He said he would not necessarily judge one of his decisions by how it turned out. Luck plays too large a role in almost every pursuit. Instead, he asks a different question: Was the decision made using the information available at the time, and was that information analyzed correctly?
That sounds simple. It isn’t.
Organizations constantly reward bad decisions that happened to work and punish good decisions that ran into bad luck. A risky initiative succeeds and the person who pushed it becomes a star. Another leader makes a careful, evidence-based choice, gets hit by something no one could reasonably have predicted, and suddenly everyone wants to know who made the mistake. Over time this teaches people exactly the wrong lesson. Leaders learn to avoid intelligent risk. They become overly confident in decisions that may never work again.
The better discipline is to separate decision quality from outcome quality. After an important decision, go back to what was knowable when the choice was made: What evidence did we have? What assumptions did we rely on? What alternatives did we consider? What did we overlook that we reasonably could have known?
When’s the last time you judged one of your own decisions by how it turned out instead of by what you knew at the time? I’d like to hear about it.
Listen to or read a transcript of my interview with Robert Rosenkranz [here].
