A donor I respect once decided, with great care and the best intentions, exactly what a community needed. He funded it generously. It was a good idea. And not one person from that community had been asked.
There is a hard argument about philanthropy that those of us in it would often rather not hear. That private giving on any significant scale is not simply a good deed but an exercise of power. The turning of private wealth into public influence. And that this power is largely unaccountable in a way that should trouble anyone who takes democracy seriously.
When someone with resources decides which problems matter, which solutions get funded, which institutions change their behavior, they are shaping public life in ways most people cannot, and in ways no one voted to grant them. I have come to believe the worst thing a person of means can do with this argument is dismiss it, because it is substantially right, and the people who dismiss it are usually the ones who most need to hear it.
Meaning well does not answer it. A foundation full of good people is still an unaccountable concentration of influence over public outcomes, and good intentions are not the same as legitimacy.
This is not a reason for guilt or paralysis, and it is certainly not a reason to stop. It is a reason to give differently. As though you understood that your power over public life was never granted to you by the people it affects.
In practice that means building accountability back into your giving where the law does not require it. Sharing the authority to define what matters with the people actually affected.
Resisting the temptation to make your influence permanent and unchecked. Treating the communities you serve as the rightful authors of the good you fund in their name, rather than the grateful recipients of your judgment.
Give as though your power were borrowed. It is, and the giving is better for remembering it.
So a question for anyone who gives, or leads an organization that lives on giving. The last time you decided what a community needed, how many people from that community helped you decide? And what would change if they had?
