I was in the back of a board meeting last year when the flagship program came up for its annual renewal. It passed unanimously, between the finance report and the lunch order, in less time than it takes to read this note.
That program had been renewed exactly the same way for thirty years.
Not one person in that room was careless. They were devoted people protecting something they loved. But not one of them could remember the last time anyone asked the only question that mattered. Does this still work, or have we simply gotten very good at keeping it running?
This is the quiet tragedy of the nonprofit board. Continuation is the default. Ending something takes courage, a fight, and usually a crisis, so almost nothing ever ends. It just accumulates, year after year, until the organization becomes a museum of decisions no one in the room still remembers making.
Most boards have never once voted to end something that was still running. And they call that stability.
Here is the move almost no leader will make. Put your model on a clock. Require the board to actively re-authorize the core program every three years, with expiration as the default if no one will stand up and make the live case to continue it. Flip the burden of proof. Make survival earn its place instead of inheriting it.
A program that still works will win that vote in a walk. A program that only survives out of habit never should have.
For the board members and chief executives here: when did your board last seriously discuss ending a program that was still running just fine? Name the moment, not the theory.
I suspect the silence in the comments will say as much as the stories do.
