A development officer recently told me something that sounded like progress.

“I can draft a donor letter in 30 seconds now.”

Five years ago that letter would have taken an hour. Maybe two. You would stare at a blank screen. Delete three openings. Rewrite the paragraph that sounded too institutional. Try to imagine the donor reading it.
Now the machine does the first pass.

It feels like a win. 

But there is a quiet danger hiding inside that efficiency.

Across industries there is a growing concern about something called deskilling—what happens when machines take over complex work and humans slowly lose the ability to do it themselves. Airline pilots have experienced it as cockpits became automated. Physicians are seeing it as diagnostic tools grow more powerful.

The same thing may now be coming for the nonprofit sector.

Right now organizations everywhere are racing to adopt AI. Drafting donor communications. Summarizing research. Generating case statements. Writing social media posts.

Individually, every one of these choices makes sense. Faster output. Lower cost. Fewer late nights.

But look at what we may be trading away.

Over the next two decades, roughly $124 trillion will move from one generation to the next. Much of that capital will flow through philanthropy.

That transfer will not be decided by whoever has the most efficient email generator.

It will be decided in conversations.

In living rooms. Over coffee. Across conference tables.

And the leaders who succeed will be the ones who can read what is happening in those rooms.

They will notice the moment a donor’s posture shifts when legacy comes up.

They will hear hesitation before the donor even voices it.

They will know when to stop presenting slides and start listening to a story about someone’s father, or sister, or child.

Those abilities are not soft skills.

They are the hardest skills in the sector.

And they are exactly the kind of skills that weaken when you stop using them.

If AI drafts every donor letter, people stop practicing how to write one.
If AI summarizes every community meeting, leaders stop learning how to truly hear one.

The efficiency is real.
So is the erosion.

The organizations that will lead the next decade will not be the ones that adopt AI the fastest.

They will be the ones that decide which human capabilities are too important to outsource— and protect those fiercely.

So here is the leadership question this week:

Share This: