In 1985, Elyse Cherry was a young associate at Hale and Dorr, one of Boston’s most prestigious law firms, when friends approached her with a problem. They were trying to develop housing in low-income communities, but capital was scarce and expertise even scarcer. If something went wrong downtown, six developers would line up to fix it. If something went wrong in a struggling neighborhood, you got a hole in the ground for 30 years.
Cherry and her colleagues started BlueHub Capital with $3,500 from the Old South Meeting House social action committee. Four decades later, that tiny seed has grown into more than $3 billion in direct lending and nearly $17 billion in total economic development across 42 states. But the real story is not the numbers. The real story is how Cherry built an organization that serves two masters equally well: the communities that need capital and the institutions that provide it.
Positioned Between Two Worlds
From the beginning, BlueHub understood something most community development organizations missed. Success required more than good intentions or proximity to need. It required what Cherry calls standing at the intersection of downtown and community, one foot planted firmly in each world.
“We really did set up as an intermediary, and that was from the very beginning,” Cherry explains. “Whether you’re borrowing from individuals or large national banks, they’re not inclined to lend you a second time if you lose their money the first time. So we had to be successful not just from the perspective of the project itself, but from the perspective of the community and our capital partners.”
This dual accountability shaped everything BlueHub touched. Projects had to pencil out financially while genuinely serving community needs. Loan structures had to satisfy institutional investors while remaining flexible enough for real-world challenges. The organization had to maintain impeccable credit while taking risks conventional lenders would not touch.
Cherry is blunt about the stakes. “We did not want to be an organization that said, ‘Oh well, we gave it a great try.’ We wanted to be an organization that was really successful.” That commitment to success, not as rhetoric but as measurable performance, became BlueHub’s calling card and competitive advantage.
When the Housing Market Collapsed
Nothing tested that commitment like the Great Recession. As housing values plummeted and unemployment soared, foreclosures threatened to devastate the communities BlueHub served. Homeowners owed $500,000 on houses now worth $300,000. They had lost their jobs and could not make payments. Conventional wisdom said let the market clear.
Cherry saw something else: an entire generation of wealth about to vanish from communities that had almost none to begin with. So BlueHub created the SUN initiative, a foreclosure prevention program that restructured mortgages for underwater homeowners.
The model was elegant in its fairness. BlueHub would buy distressed mortgages at current market value, say $300,000 instead of $500,000. Homeowners would be released from $200,000 in debt and start earning equity immediately at the new, lower value. In exchange, they would share future appreciation proportionally with BlueHub. When the home eventually returned to $500,000 in value, the homeowner would be $120,000 ahead, even after sharing appreciation.
Getting there required months of negotiation with skeptical lenders. “They said, ‘Not in a million years! If we just allow people not to pay their mortgages and then reduce what they owe, why would anybody pay a mortgage?’” Cherry recalls. But BlueHub’s reputation as a reliable partner made the difference. Lenders trusted that Cherry would not abuse the model or leave them exposed.
The results speak for themselves. BlueHub has prevented nearly 1,250 foreclosures, saved families an average of more than $90,000 each, and returned better than $67 million in equity to communities. “These days, people talk a lot about the wealth gap,” Cherry notes. “We’ve actually managed to put real dollars back into communities.”
Preparing for an Uncertain Future
Today, Cherry faces a different kind of challenge. Federal support for affordable housing and community development has become genuinely uncertain for the first time in four decades. Subsidies that developers counted on may disappear. Programs that provided critical gap financing may get cut. The rules of the game are shifting in real time.
“We can’t predict the future, but we can certainly prepare for the future,” Cherry says. “And that’s really what we’re trying to do because there is an enormous level of uncertainty at the moment.”
BlueHub’s response has been methodical. The organization is conducting careful portfolio reviews, examining not just current loans but downstream risks. Will a developer who borrows construction financing be able to secure permanent financing? Will subsidies still exist when a project needs them? Can borrowers weather cutbacks in Section 8 vouchers or other federal programs?
At the same time, BlueHub is investing in its own capacity. The organization recently hired its first chief information officer and is building an internal system to harness its institutional knowledge. Think of it as a private ChatGPT trained on 40 years of loans, projects, and outcomes. The goal is not to replace human judgment but to accelerate it. Instead of spending days tracking down comparable deals, staff will ask the system and get answers in seconds.
“The idea is not to impose AI in the community,” Cherry explains. “The idea is to use AI internally so that we can access our own history and information in ways that allow us to make better decisions.”
The Long View
After 40 years, Cherry has strong opinions about what works and what does not. Perfection, she argues, is overvalued, too expensive, and generally not useful. What matters is whether your work helps build the world you want.
“I gave a speech a very long time ago when I graduated from law school, and one of the things I said was that the world I wanted was a world in which equality, now I think I would say equity, was a given, not a goal,” Cherry reflects. “And that’s really what we’ve been working toward all these years.”
That vision has informed every choice BlueHub has made, from the projects it finances to the partnerships it builds to the risks it takes. Housing alone is not enough. Families need food security, good schools, healthcare, safe neighborhoods, and economic opportunity. Breaking the cycle of poverty requires an integrated approach, not a series of one-off interventions.
Cherry also believes effective organizations must change to meet evolving community needs. Proximity matters, but so does access to capital and expertise. Standing at the intersection means listening carefully to both sides, not choosing one over the other.
Perhaps most importantly, Cherry insists on starting before everything is perfect. “You really have to figure out if you can look down the road far enough, and then you begin,” she says. Too many good ideas die waiting for ideal conditions that never arrive. BlueHub started with $3,500 and figured the rest out along the way.
Four decades later, that willingness to begin, to learn from failure without aiming for it, and to serve two masters with equal integrity has produced something rare: a community development finance institution trusted by Wall Street and Main Street alike. That is the intermediary advantage, and Elyse Cherry has spent a career proving it works.
To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com
