There is a graveyard of good ideas in the social sector, and it is larger than anyone wants to admit.

A solution that cut maternal mortality in half during its pilot. An education platform that tripled literacy rates in rural communities. A clean water system that cost one-tenth of existing alternatives. All of them worked. All of them had the data. All of them died anyway.

Not from lack of passion. Not from bad execution. They died in what Hala Hanna calls the Valley of Death, that brutal stretch between proof of concept and sustainability where even brilliant innovations suffocate. Caught between philanthropic funders who demand certainty and impact investors who want market returns from ventures serving people the market has abandoned, these entrepreneurs run out of road.

I have watched this tragedy unfold for fifty years. What makes it worse is how unnecessary it is. The entrepreneurs exist. The capital exists. What is missing is the courage to connect them.

Beating Y Combinator at Its Own Game
Here is a number that should make every foundation board member sit up: 94 percent. That is MIT Solve’s five-year survival rate for the social entrepreneurs they support. Y Combinator, the gold standard of startup accelerators, hits 70 percent. We are talking about entrepreneurs serving the hardest-to-reach populations, working on the most complex problems, operating in the most difficult environments. And they are outlasting startups chasing middle-class consumers in wealthy markets.

How? Hala Hanna points first to lived experience. Eighty-five percent of MIT Solve’s entrepreneurs have walked in the shoes of the people they serve. These founders do not leave when someone offers them fifty thousand dollars more to work on something easier. The mission is not a career move. It is personal.

Then there is what happens when someone believes in you early. For every dollar MIT Solve gives in prizes, their entrepreneurs raise 426 dollars over their lifetime. Their for-profit ventures have collectively raised 1.1 billion dollars. This is not charity creating dependency. This is catalytic capital unlocking multiples in follow-on investment by signaling that someone credible has done the hard work of vetting.

Take Temie Giwa-Tubosun and LifeBank. After nearly dying from blood loss during an emergency C-section in the United States, Temie realized she would not have survived that same birth in her home country of Nigeria. So she built a delivery system for oxygen, blood, and time-sensitive medical supplies using satellites, WhatsApp, and motorcycles nimble enough to navigate Lagos traffic. Nothing fancy. Just appropriate technology solving a lifeor- death problem. She now saves millions of lives every year. When MIT Solve selected her as a Solver, she met Merck for Mothers at their event. That introduction led to a five million dollar partnership.

The Mechanisms That Betray Our Values
Hanna is too diplomatic to say it directly, but I am not. We have built philanthropic systems that replicate the very inequities we claim to fight. Closed networks. Opaque selection. The same organizations funded over and over because they are known quantities. Safe bets that produce modest outcomes while transformative ideas die from neglect.

The numbers tell the story. Two hundred fifty billion dollars sitting in donor-advised funds. A four trillion dollar gap to achieve the UN Sustainable Development Goals. The capital exists. The entrepreneurs exist. But somehow we cannot get the money to the people who know how to use it.

When I asked Hanna why courage remains so rare among funders, she turned the question back on me, curious what I was seeing after hundreds of conversations with philanthropic leaders. Here is what I told her. It comes down to fear. Fear of the one investment that does not work, even when nine others succeed. Fear of standing out. Fear of the annual report that has to justify every dollar to a board that thinks safety equals fiduciary responsibility.

Too many philanthropic advisors are optimizing for tax benefits rather than human impact. They come from wealth management, not social change. They recommend the same established organizations because it feels responsible, never asking whether responsible is the same as effective. The client gets a tax deduction and a warm feeling. The world gets incrementalism.

When AI Could Go Either Way
Only 1 percent of AI investment flows to social impact. Of that slim fraction, just 10 percent reaches low and middle-income countries. The most powerful technology in a generation is being built almost entirely for people who already have resources and opportunity.

But Hanna sees another pattern in MIT Solve’s portfolio. Solutions using AI reach twice as many people as those that do not. The difference is data localization. Speetar, a platform in Libya, turned every doctor and primary healthcare provider into a data contributor, capturing information in the Libyan dialect. That specificity makes the AI work for those populations in ways that models trained in California or Beijing never could.

Khushi Baby has become the backbone of the health sector in three Indian provinces, reaching 27 million people. Rocket Learning reaches 3 million children across ten states, improving education outcomes by 30 percent for a dollar fifty per child per year. These are not charity cases limping along. These are sophisticated technology companies operating at scale for a fraction of what traditional development programs cost.

From Bunker to Boardroom
Hanna grew up in Beirut during the civil war. At four years old, she thought running to the basement during bombings was a game. Her favorite snack was canned hotdog on pita bread because it was all her family had. Children, she says, have a superpower. They can reinterpret reality and find joy even in a bunker.

But she refuses to romanticize that resilience. Every parent of the hundreds of millions of children growing up in conflict zones today loves their child just as much. Those kids deserve more than luck. We owe them more than that.

That conviction drives everything at MIT Solve. Not false optimism. Not better storytelling about a harsh reality. But backing people who refuse to wait for permission, who see a problem and change the stakes today.

The Choice We Make
The Valley of Death is not some inevitable feature of social innovation. It is a choice we make every time we prioritize safety over impact, every time we fund the known over the transformative, every time we mistake risk avoidance for responsible stewardship.

MIT Solve has proven there is another way. A 94 percent survival rate. Three hundred seventy million lives impacted. One point one billion dollars in follow-on investment unlocked by 80 million in catalytic funding. These numbers are not lucky accidents. They are what happens when you get the model right.

The entrepreneurs are out there. The solutions exist. The only question is whether we have the courage to back them.


To celebrate my 50th year in the nonprofit sector, I’ve put together a gift for you — a practical, field-tested guide to building world-class nonprofit workplace cultures. It’s called Cultivating Nonprofit Excellence, and it’s based on insights from nearly 1,000 interviews and 150 focus groups with nonprofit leaders around the globe. It’s completely free and instantly downloadable at blanchedalmond-mosquito-418475.hostingersite.com 

Share This: